Showing posts with label Southeast Asia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Southeast Asia. Show all posts

Thursday, July 14, 2011

Indonesia and the Ultimate Tobacco Ban Protest

Just look at the size of that sucker. Philip Morris, eat your heart out! I am genuinely of two minds over cigarette smoking bans being imposed throughout the world. The Emmanuel that wants to live a reasonably healthy lifestyle abhors the practice and the many diseases it gives rise to. But, the relatively live and let live me grants that persons have a genuine right to severely impair their health under certain conditions. Truth be told, I have no problems with requiring tobacco firms to place graphic warnings on the dangers of their products--see the recent US FDA graphics (and I do mean graphic). If adults still persist in smoking after seeing these warnings, well, that's their prerogative.

However, both tendencies clash when it comes to smoking in public places. Aside from the offputting aroma, we also have to deal with the reality of second-hand smoke which has been found to be exceedingly unhealthy as well. For example: how far should we go in dissuading smoking from, say, hangouts where people traditionally indulge in vices to (literally) let off some steam? Here in the UK, there is an ongoing debate as to whether thousands of pubs have found their business diminished since smoking bans were instituted at these places. There's even an online petition movement clamouring for a change.

These debates on smoking are now moving to the developing world as tobacco giants join local firms in trying to expand their business there. Call it regulatory arbitrage as laws become more onerous for selling tobacco in the industrialized world--for now. In Indonesia, tobacco farmers want to sabotage legislation that would (1) limit tobacco advertising, (2) place graphic warnings on tobacco products, and (3) ban smoking in public places. Sounds familiar, eh? However, I was particularly taken by the antics of tobacco farmers protesting the bill such as with the "megarette" above. My blogging affiliates at Global Post have more fun if ludicrously unhealthy images. What follows though is a summary of the legislation which has incited the most colourful libertarian--ish protests IMHO from Berita Jakarta:
Thousands of tobacco farmers from various regions who incorporated in Kretek Rescue National Coalition (KNPK)[kretek is the Indonesian term for flavoured cigarettes] demonstrated by surrounding the State Palace on Jl. Medan Merdeka Utara, Central Jakarta. In this action, they demanded the Act Draft (RUU) about Control of Tobacco Products Impact for Health and the Regulation Implementation Draft (RPP) of Security on Materials Containing Addictive Substance in form of Tobacco Products to be canceled.

Abhisam Demosa as Head of National Kretek said the rules were feared threatened the life of tobacco farmers and workers in Indonesia. “It could also threaten the hawkers and cigarettes seller agents,” he expressed, Wednesday. Besides carried coffins [ironic, this], demonstrators also brought a property of big cigarette which burned and smoked alternately. Because of this demonstration, traffic flows in front of the State Palace severely congested. In fact, Jl. Veteran III was closed temporarily.

Hundreds of security officers stand by at the scene equipped with two units of water canon car and one unit of barracuda. To block demonstrators, officers installed barbed wires along 100 meters from the State Palace. This demonstration did not only cause congestion in front of the State Palace, but also on Jl. Veterean, Jl. Merdeka Barat towards HI Roundabout and vice versa, as well as around Harmoni area.
Smoke 'em if you got 'em? These habits are dying hard throughout the world.

Sunday, July 10, 2011

Harry Potter and Hollywood Gone AWOL in Indonesia

This being on my purported beat of Southeast Asia, here's some interesting news. One of the more practical applications for those studying political science / international relations is the area of "political risk analysis." In particular, there is concern by foreign investors of how shifting political winds affect the climate for their businesses, the ultimate Bad Thing being uncompensated expropriation. But there are many other irritants that may yet cause foreign firms to throw their hands up in frustration. Frustrating enough to keep the final instalment of Harry Potter from the world's fourth most populous country.

For your consideration, today we have Harry Potter and Hollywood Gone AWOL in Indonesia. No, JK Rowling has not quite reneged on having written the last novel about Harry Potter. Besides, I doubt whether she would have penned something with such a mouthful title for Year 8. Rather, this story is Based on Real Life and is occurring right now in Indonesia.

There are two opposing versions here. Both concern the largest motion picture chain in Indonesia, the Cineplex 21 Group, and regulations supposedly introduced at the start of the year on taxes and royalties due to the government from those showing Hollywood blockbusters. The Motion Picture Association (MPA) representing the largest US firms have worked with Cineplex 21 for the longest time, and it is the latter which has come under fire the most from Indonesian government officials. While Cineplex 21 claims it was not aware of the new regulations coming into effect (which obviously require larger payments being made to the government), the authorities point out that Cineplex 21 has been recalcitrant in paying up.

So, with the largest Indonesian movie chain not being able to show first-run Hollywood movies over alleged arrears--the very same one which has an exclusive deal to show such movies in the country--they've been screening nearly everything else to the annoyance of local filim buffs. As with other American commercial interests facing fettered access, this has become a full-blown trade issue:
Debates over the absence of Hollywood movies at local cinemas have gone bilateral, with Indonesia asking the US to find other importers to end the five-month Hollywood movie drought amid the summer blockbuster season. Local importers, which have the exclusive rights to import Hollywood blockbusters, have suspended import activities since January as they settle tax cases in court involving Rp 300 billion (US$35.09 million) in royalty fees and penalties in arrears. The importers said they were never aware of such obligations.

Ever since, Indonesians enjoying the luxury of movie theaters in 65 cities across the country have been screening lower-quality flicks such as Beastly and What Women Want, while much-awaited blockbuster films such as Black Swan and Kung Fu Panda 2 are nowhere to be seen. “In the [bilateral] meeting, which was also attended by the US ambassador, we said there were many importers willing to work with them,” Finance Minister Agus Martowardojo said over the weekend.

Indonesia’s cinema industry has long been dominated by the Cineplex 21 Group, which acts as both importer and distributor and also owns the largest theater chain. Of 600 total theaters in the country, about 500 are owned by the 21 Cineplex Group, 50 by Blitz Megaplex and the remaining by various other businesses. Ananda Siregar, CEO of the second-largest theater chain, Blitz Megaplex, has tried to contact the Motion Picture Association (MPA) to take over import activities, but failed as Hollywood distributors have agreements with the Cineplex 21 Group. MPA represents major Hollywood studios such as Twentieth Centry Fox, Paramount, Sony Pictures Entertainment, Walt Disney Studios and Warner Bros.

Finance Ministry Director General of Taxation Agung Kuswandono said last week that there have been importation requests from new firms to ship foreign movies. “But I don’t know if they are [affiliated] with the existing players or not.” If they are affiliated with existing players, Agung added, they might not be allowed to import. “We are not only banning the company, but also the directors. So, we need to look at it first, to see if these [new importers] are only an effort to shift position from being banned to being allowed [to import].”

In the meeting conducted on Tuesday, both the Indonesian and the United States governments have also called the “Hollywood boycott” bogus, Agus said. “The American representatives clearly understood that Indonesia has no problem with American film exporters, producers or government. but there is a problem that needs to be solved by [local] importers that have been acting as American film importers for the MPA.”

From the fiscal front, the government has pushed efforts to ease importation of foreign movies by simplifying import procedures for foreign movie importers. The Finance Ministry stopped the royalty fee requirement, but instead imposed a new duties system that requires importers to pay import duties of Rp 21,000 to Rp 22,000 per minute for each copy of a film they brought into the country.
There was an earlier hope that instead of being taxed a fixed proportion of gate receipts which MPA rejected as being too prohibitive, a tax on film length in minutes would solve the impasse. However, as the article above suggests, the Indonesian government appears keener on ending the "Hollywood boycott" not by making terms more favourable to 21 Cineplex but by giving the franchise of distributing Hollywood films to other importers. Like many things in Southeast Asia, I suspect these rule changes have more to do with certain interests wanting something done with 21 Cineplex as opposed to regulatory opaqueness.

Sunday, July 3, 2011

Avast Ye Furriners! Arab Spring and 'Saudization'

One of the more interesting angles that migration researchers have focused on in recent years has been that of South-South migration. While the common perception we have of economic migration is of those from developing countries travelling to developed countries, about half of all migration occurs between developing countries themselves. That is, there are gradations of economic development and opportunity between, say, Ukraine and Russia or Bangladesh and India.

It is well-known that workers with various skill levels ranging from Sri Lankan construction workers at one end to British bankers at the other have travelled to the Middle East in droves over several decades. Aside from providing manpower that relatively small countries there lack, they provide technical expertise not necessarily found among Mideast elites. Right? Well, maybe not for so much longer. As the Arab Spring seems to be demonstrating, there is a lack of employment opportunities for Arab youth in many of the MENA countries, often resulting in outpourings of negative sentiment against monarchical classes. But, it also poses the question of how much citizens of these countries would tolerate '3D'-type jobs: difficult, dangerous or dirty.

As a student of regional integration schemes, one of the common refrains you get from the Gulf Cooperation Council is to hire less foreign workers and employ more locals. Like in other regions, skilled migration that aims to keep talent within the Middle East is a common objective. Here is a typical example:
Implementing the Supreme Council’s resolution in the previous session with regard to employment of the national work force, and in order to facilitate their mobility from one Member State to another; and with a view to increasing the job opportunities for the GCC citizens and to nationalize jobs in the various sectors, and to achieve coordination among the Member States in this field, the Supreme Council approved the views of the Consultative Commission in this regard. The Council decided to assign the Consultative Commission with the task of undertaking an evaluation of the process of joint action in the field of economy, asking it to present its views in the 21st session of the Supreme Council.
Again, it seems the Arab Spring has spurred efforts to employ more locals. Take Saudi Arabia, for instance. For years and years, Saudi Arabia has been among the top destinations for Filipino migrants. While they have a fairly vast range of skill levels, Philippine employment authorities are keeping a close eye on lower-skilled migration in particular as a programme of 'Saudization' takes place. Various news outlets have bandied about massive figures on how much Saudi powers-that-be are spending to buy off dissent and discontent; some say this amounts to up to $130 billion. But, aside from that massive sum, how do you create a more sustainable way of dealing with pent-up demand for domestic employment? Answer: you finally deliver on promises to hire fewer foreigners and more nationals. From the Philippine Star:
The implementation of the new hiring policy in Saudi Arabia, also known as the “Saudization” program, may displace 90,000 low-skilled workers, the Department of Labor and Employment said yesterday. Labor Secretary Rosalinda Baldoz said the Philippine government is assessing the impact of the new policy on Filipino workers employed by small establishments.

The Saudi Labor Ministry is classifying 300,000 local companies into four categories: excellent and green (complying companies), and yellow and red (non-complying companies). Local firms will be required to hire a minimum number of Saudi citizens. The categorization is expected to be completed on Aug. 30.

Baldoz assured Filipinos employed in Saudi that the government is prepared to act on the challenge of the new policy. She said the Philippine labor offices in the kingdom are educating Filipino workers on the impact of the program.
So they're even going to colour-code firms based on certain hiring criteria of Saudis--the exact formula is not exactly known. (There's also the assertion of Philippine central bankers that many of those heading to Saudi Arabia are now more highly-skilled to contend with.) However, one thing I will readily concede is that there is likely a sizeable number of young unemployed locals. Arab News offers this take on 'Saudization':
Saudi Arabia announced Sunday new plans to intensify the Saudization of jobs in private companies as part of efforts to reduce the unemployment rate. According to official statistics, there are more than 448,000 Saudi jobseekers, including women, in a country with eight million expatriate workers.

Labor Minister Adel Fakieh said private companies would be classified into green, yellow and red categories considering their performance in the Saudization of jobs. “We have set out new standards to assess the employment of Saudis in private firms. We have differentiated between companies that have achieved high Saudization rates and those refusing to employ Saudis,” he said.

He said companies in the red category would be prevented from renewing work visas of their expatriate workers while companies in the green category would be allowed to select foreign workers in the other two categories and transfer their sponsorship without the approval of theirs employers.

Fakieh said the new Saudization plan has been designed to keep most private companies in the green category and considering the reality of the labor market. He said details of additional incentives given to Saudization-friendly green companies would be announced on June 11 on the ministry’s website.
It's not as if Saudization hasn't been tried before. Yet the aforementioned payments and wage hikes aside, the events currently engulfing the Gulf seems to have forced the Saudi authorities' hand in a more pronounced fashion:
The new measures came after Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques King Abdullah set up a high-level ministerial committee to find a quick way to employ the growing number of graduates in public and private sectors. The king increased the minimum salary of Saudis to SR3,000 and ordered payment of a SR2,000 monthly allowance for the jobless.

Fakieh acknowledged that the real number of the unemployed could be higher than 448,000, because of the increasing number of Saudi university graduates. He also pointed out that about six million of the country’s eight million expatriates work in the private sector. “These expatriate workers cost the Kingdom SR98 billion annually in terms of transfer of salaries to accounts in their respective countries,” the minister said. “They also put additional pressure on the country’s infrastructure and service sectors.”

Fakieh said there was a five-percent annual rise in the number of expatriate workers, which is double the size of annual Saudi population increase. “This increase of expatriates is causing imbalance in the job market and preventing Saudis to get jobs in private companies. Most companies prefer to employ expatriates as they are ready to accept low salaries,” he pointed out.

He said the new measures were taken as previous Saudization plans were not successful due to various reasons. Saudis working in private companies do not exceed more than 10 percent of the total workforce. He also pointed out that 84 percent of expatriate workers carry only secondary school certificates, adding that these unskilled expatriates could be replaced by Saudis gradually.

Fakieh said companies who had poor Saudization record would be given a time limit to change the situation before preventing them from enjoying the new facilities and incentives. “Saudization has become a national necessity rather than a choice,” the minister said, adding that it would boost the economy.
My question is simple and hearkens back to what I stated earlier: given that many of the jobs on offer will be to of the '3D' difficult, dangerous or dirty variety, what guarantee is there that Saudi nationals will readily fill these posts when foreigners will no longer be allowed to occupy them? For instance, the burgeoning number of university graduates is mentioned, but wouldn't they be seeking white-collar employment more than low-skilled work?

As they say, it's very much a work in progress.

Wednesday, June 29, 2011

The PRC@LSE, Niall Ferguson and Me

From left to right: your humble IPE blogger (in need of a haircut), Li Fan who is Deputy Director of the Department of Policy Planning at the Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs, and Niall Ferguson who is Philippe Roman Chair for 2010-2011

"Emmanuel, let's take a photo with Professor Ferguson before the LSE IDEAS sign!" said my colleague from the Chinese Foreign Ministry, Dr Li Fan at our farewell party yesterday for The Ascent of Money guy. Despite being somewhat miffed at the Chinese government at the moment for largely unexplained strong-arm tactics over the South China Sea--or the West Philippine Sea as our local media now calls it--I couldn't begrudge the kindly Li Fan. Hence the photo. Having completed compulsory military training, I am of course subject to being called up to serve in the Armed Forces of the Philippines. While the prospects are remote, I have enduring anxieties about being sent to certain death defending Philippine interests in the Spratly Islands against the vastly superior PLA. I'm not keen on suicide missions.

At any rate, I am sure that I've mentioned that PRC Foreign Minister Yang Jiechi is an alumni of the LSE. Being ever so fond of his alma mater (or something to that effect), they send ministry officials to visit us as Chevening Programme Visiting Fellows every half a year or so. These fellowships are partly funded by HM Foreign and Commonwealth Office and they provide an opportunity for us to interact with the current batch of Chinese policymakers. Certainly, it lets us at LSE IDEAS--staffed as it is with former diplomats--understand our counterparts in the world's rising power that little bit better.

You would expect me to say this about my employers, but the basic idea underpinning our work here at LSE IDEAS is conceptually sound: by gathering academics, diplomats and policymakers under one roof, we are able to draw from a wider range of ideas in solving questions of diplomacy, strategy and international affairs. Oftentimes academia degenerates into something isolated and impractical with lots of number-crunching for its own sake but with few policy implications. We try to strike a balance: while we attract folks like Niall Ferguson who offer distinctive (if controversial) perspectives on various economic phenomena, we too welcome diplomats who actually *do* international relations.

Though he has his detractors, Henry Kissinger who Professor Ferguson is preparing a biography about could never be accused of being a bookish academic as he hosted the now-famous Harvard International Seminar which featured many names who would soon be a who's who of global leadership in the sixties. I wonder why Americans don't have a similar programme: instead of churning blood-curdling invectives against the PRC on a regular basis, why doesn't the US have a diplomatic outreach effort centred on academic exchange to learn more about those conducting foreign policy in China? If a second-string world power does it, why not America? Though I often am at odds with what Niall Ferguson writes, I fully agree that the US has no grand strategy at the present time which it used to have with Kissinger.

I've learned quite a lot from interacting with my PRC colleagues since they are seated right next to me. Although they are quite often quick to toe the (Chinese Communist) party line when in doubt, there are moments of candour which I value as a citizen of one of China's smaller neighbours.

The occasion for this photo is the impending departure of Niall Ferguson from our happy little camp in Holborn.The day before that, Li Fan explained "What China Wants" in compressed form as she too is leaving soon for Beijing. It should thus surprise no one that my time here is limited as well since I will depart for parts unknown in due course. There's a big world out there and I shall be taking the IPE Zone show on the road for the umpteenth time. But, it will be good to recall a time when I was at the centre of it all with diplomats from the world's rising power and the famously itinerant economic historian of our age, among others.

Monday, June 20, 2011

Change 'South China Sea' to 'Southeast Asia Sea'

Here we go again, another South China Sea entry after I'd written about the issue in recent months [1, 2, 3]. I am of two minds about this new petition circulating among those of us from Southeast Asia to change our term for the 'South China Sea' to the 'Southeast Asia Sea'. (This one comes from the US-based Nguyen Thai Hoc Foundation named after the Vietnamese nationalist executed by French imperialists.) It comes amidst new quarrels between China on one hand and the Philippines and Vietnam on the other over dominion over these strategically important waters. To be sure, Southeast Asia is emerging on the global stage in its own right not just as an appendage of China. Geographically speaking, 'Southeast Asia Sea' is also more accurate given the rather sweeping claims China has on the region.

Should I sign on to the many who've added their names to the petition? The Spratly Islands issue continues to be a highly visible demonstration of how the 'Chinese Communist Party' is not a monolithic entity. Different ministries often do not act in a coordinated fashion. While the People's Liberation Army (PLA) is very gung-ho on the matter, other bodies alike China's trade ministry is more cautious, likely preferring that the matter would go away altogether. For, China has in recent years become Southeast Asia's largest trading partner, and those who have built up such linkages would be understandably reluctant to strain these ties as the PRC seeks to consolidate its backyard. So, in this interpretation, the PRC would lose next to no sleep if Southeast Asians began calling it whatever they wish.

But, the other thing to remember is that China would likely annihilate whatever navies the Philippines and Vietnam could muster if push comes to shove. On the open seas, insurgency tactics against superior forces are not usually effective. Would it act so rashly as to violate the 2002 Declaration on the Conduct of Parties in the South China Sea?I surely hope not.

In any event, those promoting this petition generally believe that a change of terms can affect the tone of the debate. There are arguably better reasons for calling it the 'Southeast Asia Sea' than its current name. Aside from removing the parochial Sinic overtones--it's called the South China Sea, so it must 'belong' to China--it also has the potential to improve Southeast Asian identity at a time when its countries are also emerging alike Indonesia being included in the G-20.

The Philippine Star has an article briefly describing the petition:
A petition to change the name “South China Sea” to “Southeast Asia Sea” has been launched, with 43,109 signatures posted online so far for its approval. According to online social network www.Changeorg., the Nguyen Thai Hoc Foundation, a group of volunteers campaigning for “a modern and civilized attitude” around the world, started the petition in November last year.

In its petition, the group said the United Nations has officially recognized Southeast Asia as a region encompassing almost the entire South China Sea. The South China Sea has a coastline of about 130,000 kilometers (81,250 miles) while Southern China’s coastline measured only about 2,800 kilometers (1,750 miles), it explained. “The freedom of navigation on the sea is not restricted to a specific country and is a common heritage of mankind,” the group said. “It has actually been used by the international community for centuries as the second most important water channel in the world, and therefore must be considered a common ground.”

The petition had been sent to presidents and prime ministers of the 11 Southeast Asian countries, the Secretary General of the United Nations, the United Nations Atlas of the Oceans, Geographic Society of 10 countries, including Australia, Canada, European Union, France, Germany, India, Japan, South Korea, United Kingdom, Russia, and the United States, and over 10,000 people from 77 countries around the world.

“In this modern era, as human civilization evolved towards a multi-faceted global collaboration, the international community, since the 20th century, has geographically formed a sub-region in Asia to address mankind’s need,” the group said.

“This region was officially named Southeast Asia and consists of Burma, Brunei, Cambodia, East Timor, Indonesia, Laos, Malaysia, Singapore, Thailand, the Philippines, and Vietnam...Southeast Asia represents approximately 600 million people who have, in a joint effort, made unique and original contributions to modern civilization in culture, science, education, economics, politics.” South China Sea must therefore be named Southeast Asia Sea, the group said.
Decisions, decisions. Sign up if you must. I certainly won't dissuade you, but I am still weighing the pros and cons at the moment. Still, I must admire this show of Southeast Asian unity because there is honestly so little of it that I can observe.

Tuesday, May 24, 2011

Realizing the ($134 Trillion GDP) Asian Century

With all due to apologies to the late economic historian Angus Maddison (requiescat in pace), will half of world GDP be accounted for by Asia in 2050? It may seem a far-fetched notion now, but the Asian Development Bank has a new report out which suggests it's within the bounds of plausibility.

The key to achieving this feat says the ADB is for populous and fast-growing China, India, Indonesia, and Vietnam (two SE Asian countries, yay!) not to fall into a middle-income trap. That is, not succumbing to slowing growth rates and concomitantly stagnating income levels in the next five to ten years. If this trap is avoided, Asian GDP may approach $148 trillion and account for 51% of global output by 2050. But, if the region falls into this trap, it will "only" account for 32% of global output with a combined GDP of $61 trillion. It almost makes you proud to be an Asian during this exciting time when old Europe and enervated America are busy competing to see who can flush their continents down the toilet of history faster (I got tired of the dustbin of history, so there).

While these eye-catching figures are more conjectural than anything else, the challenges listed of making more optimistic scenarios come true are certainly worth paying attention to as we try and realize the Asian Century. Focuses the mind, eh? What follows are the key snippets from the executive summary, though the rest is well worth reading for all of those interested in geopolitics and IPE:
Makings of the Asian Century

The Asian Century scenario essentially extends Asia’s past success into the future, putting it on the cusp of a truly historic transformation. In this scenario, Asia’s GDP (market exchange rates) would increase from $16 trillion in 2010 to $148 trillion in 2050, or half of global GDP, similar to its share of the global population. With a per capita GDP of $38,600 (PPP), Asia in 2050 would have incomes similar to Europe today. It would have no poor countries (with average per capita GDP of less than $1,000), compared with seven today. All this assumes that Asian economies can maintain their momentum for another 40 years and adapt to shifting global economic and technological environment by continually recreating their comparative advantage.

Actions at three levels

But in its march towards the Asian Century, the region must tackle daunting policy, institutional and governance challenges along the way. Given widely varying country conditions, the precise actions and their timing must vary. Still, it is possible to draw the contours of the major changes necessary for the region along three dimensions: (i) national strategic and policy actions; (ii) collective regional actions to bridge the national and global agendas; and (iii) Asia’s interactions with the global community (Figure 1). The ability of the diverse countries in Asia to realize the promise of the Asian Century will be determined by their success, individually and collectively, in addressing these imperatives.

Sunday, May 22, 2011

PRC Still Idolizes Singapore, Warts & All

While pointed commentaries in official Chinese publications on perceived slights by Westerners (particularly Americans) against China are common, you often don't see these publications going out of their way to defend others being the subject of foreign defamation. The target in question here is Singapore. A few days ago I commented on various opposition parties gaining a 40% share of the popular vote in Singapore--a one-party state since its inception under Harry Lee Kuan Yew's People's Action Party (PAP). These opposition parties would have gained a larger share of the legislature had a proportional representation (PR) system been in place instead of a first past the post one. You can certainly argue that the minuscule Workers Party gains--6 out of 87 seats--would have been greater had Singapore not been subject to fairly obvious gerrymandering.

It is a well-known story by now how Deng Xiaoping's 1978 visit to Singapore helped set China's authoritarian development plans in motion. Here was a tiny country making its way in the world without its longtime leaders losing their tight control on the reins of power. Not only has the Communist Party of China (CPC) tried to emulate the PAP, but it has also observed how Singaporean politics evolve. From the PAP website, no less:
Ties go beyond such physical developments. In 2002, Zeng Qinghong, an alternative member of the Politburo of the Communist Party of China’s (CPC) Central Committee and a member of the CPC’s Central Committee Secretariat put it in a nutshell when he received in Beijing a delegation led by PAP Central Exco member Lim Swee Say.

He said: “The CPC values learning from the PAP’s experience of governance. This has become an important element of the exchanges between both parties.” To this end, Chinese officials have sat in at meet-the-people sessions and noted PAP MPs’ familiarity with citizens’ concerns. They have gone back and launched their own regular meetings with the public.

As China’s political reforms continue, they keep returning to observe how Singapore handles other issues.
So perhaps it was never going to be the case that Singapore's recent election results would go down well with Beijing's powers-that-be. After all, here was a one-party state that delivered a high standard of living to its citizens being reprimanded by these very citizens. At the very least, let's say it's not quite conducive to continuing processes of Chinese political reform aimed at broadening public input following Singapore.

So, in this China Daily op-ed, the response is one of blaming Westerners for blowing the Singaporean elections out of proportion. Linking events in Singapore with those in the Middle East is particularly given short shrift. In a nutshell, "Westerners don't understand us Asians":
The opposition in Singapore's parliamentary elections made a breakthrough on May 7, winning six out of 87 seats in the parliament for the first time. Shortly afterwards, Lee Kuan Yew and [former PM] Goh Chok Tong announced that they would quit the cabinet, drawing more attention to the political situation in Singapore.

Many Western media agencies quickly associated the political system of Singapore with the retirement of Lee and Goh as well as the setback that the ruling party suffered in the parliamentary elections. A British media outlet published an editorial under the headline "Singapore is taking the First Steps to True Democracy," and another Western media outlet claimed in its report that Singapore has never had a "real two-party system."

The Western media said directly that the existing political system of Singapore is not "true democracy," implying that only Western democracy is the genuine democracy. Some Western media reports even related the political changes in Singapore to the unrest in West Asia and North Africa, claiming that they were all the results of the global wave of democratization.
Then the op-ed begins to conflate democratic processes with economic development:
It seems that the Western media have forgotten about Singapore's remarkable economic achievements in recent years. Singapore's GDP grew nearly 15 percent in 2010, making it the fastest-growing economy in the world, and it surpassed certain Western countries in terms of per capita income and social security coverage. However, these facts were seldom mentioned in Western media reports.

Obviously, the Western media are not interested in how Singapore achieved great economic progress because the Eastern country's successful development mode is not in line with Western democratic standards. People can be reminded of the Western media's stereotyped viewpoints by the fact that even now they still call Singapore a "dictatorship" or "quasi-dictatorship."

Objectively, the changes reflected by the elections in Singapore are mainly from two aspects. The first is the start of the adjustment to the leadership succession within the ruling party through the appointment of new leaders and the retirement of old ones. The second is the changes in the demand of the new generation of voters who hope to raise the voice of the opposition in the parliament rather than expect another party to replace the ruling People's Action Party. The adjustment and changes does not represent major unrest in Singapore's political system.
It then gets murkier with the suggestion that Singapore's woes are political rather than economic alike those of many Western countries:
Logically speaking, Singapore is already a developed country and should have the same status as developed Western countries, an assertion about which Western media agencies appear to disagree. Some Western countries are facing much more severe unrest compared with Singapore. Some European countries are deeply trapped in the debt crisis that will possibly cause a severe impact on the world economy.

However, are there any Western media agencies that have analyzed the problems in these countries from the angle of their political system? The issues facing Asian countries are surely issues involving their political systems, while the issues facing Western countries are limited to economic ones. Does this result from prejudice or ignorance?

Singapore does have its problems, but the problems facing Singapore are the ones that are emerging after it has developed to a rather high level. Public complaints about housing prices and the rise in the number of foreign workers are partly because of the higher demand generated by the people after they have led better lives and gained many benefits from development.

The future of Singapore does face challenges, but the challenges will surely not involve whether Singapore's political system will be closer to Western democracy or whether reforms coveted by some will occur. The real challenge is whether Singapore can continue the way of development that has been consistent with its context.

The political changes in West Asia and North Africa have made some Westerners more irrational about their political system and sharpened their sense of moral superiority. Such misconceptions and superiority are evidently not something constructive to the increasingly polarized world.
It's an odd mix: On one hand you have attempts towards self-reassurance--this is only a temporary setback for the PAP which has traditionally been responsive to the Singaporean people's concerns, China chose the right path in emulating Singapore, etc. On the other hand, movements towards democratization in the Middle East have also prompted suggestions that Western cultural imperialism is at work when foreign commentators mention Singapore's election results and Tunisia, Egypt, Yemen and the rest in the same breath. Doesn't raising GDP per capita justify political continuity?

In the end, there's little denying that China filters through the prism of Singapore the ides of (Arab) spring. Just as the Chinese leadership successfully navigated through the events of 1989 to outlast the Soviet Eastern bloc, so too does it see Singapore as a proxy for the durability of the (mostly economic) reforms it has undertaken since then.

Make no mistake: 1.3 billion-plus person China very closely follows political-economic evolutions in comparatively tiny Singapore and its slightly more than 5 million citizens. In turn, do not forget which country commissioned a commemorative statue of Deng Xiaoping (see image at top). This is a mutual admiration society with more than a little narcissism shared by both mentor and mentee.

Monday, May 9, 2011

Singapore One Party State? Foreign Minister Loses

When it comes to electoral exercises, Singapore's usually attract next to no global media coverage for obvious reasons. In the past, this has been taken as a "good thing" since continuity and stability have been foundational hallmarks for Singapore's economic miracle. However, a failure to report on the recent elections in the city-state does internationally-minded audiences a major disservice. Indeed, it may be a warning shot to those aspiring to imitate its much-vaunted brand of authoritarian development.

Singapore is, on the whole, better run than any number of Middle East / North African states experiencing turmoil at the moment. However, just-concluded polls seem to betray a general tiredness with Lee Kuan Yew's People's Action Party (PAP) that has been in power practically since Singapore left the Malayan Federation all those years ago. While Singaporean elections are usually a PAP blowout in no small part due to obviously curtailed political freedoms for, shall we say the "other" parties, this result was a rather unexpected one. Think of it as an upset that was made less upsetting by rather severe controls on other parties' abilities to get their message across.

This time round, PAP's saving grace appears to be sticking with a first past the post and a mostly party list-like system. For, had Singapore adopted a proportional representation system, the 40% share of the vote gathered by various opposition parties would have meant so much more than having a total of 6 out of 87 seats won by the Workers Party (one party list of 5 members in Aljunied and a single directly elected representative, Yaw Shin Leong). Still, native Singaporeans--the few of them there are--expressed wariness about expatriates competing for remunerative jobs and driving up living costs (especially of real-estate).

As it turns out, one of the scalps is long-serving Singaporean Foreign Minister George Yeo. Given the surprising magnitude of losses by Singaporean standards, let's say PAP leadership were unaware that one of their big figures was soon to bite the dust and that they would have to groom another PAP member for that particular post. Given how Singapore routinely punches above its weight in Asian diplomatic circles, this is no small beer for the tiny nation-state to deal with:
"Singapore has been left with no ready replacement for Foreign Minister George Yeo, the biggest casualty of the city state's general election, a leading think tank warned Monday. Yeo, one of Southeast Asia's best-known diplomats, led a five-member People's Action Party (PAP) ticket that was toppled by the opposition Workers' Party in Saturday's poll -- the government's worst result since independence.

One of the most significant outcomes of May 7 has been the defeat of Foreign Minister George Yeo," Simon Tay, chairman of the Singapore Institute of International Affairs, wrote in the Today newspaper. "Yeo has emerged in the international community as among the best-recognised and respected of this generation of Singaporean leaders. The next cabinet has no ready replacement for him."

While the PAP lost only six of 87 seats as a result of an electoral system in which most seats are contested in groups, its 60 percent share of all votes cast was the lowest ever for a party that has been in power for 52 years. Yeo is a former brigadier general who entered politics in 1988 and held various positions including stints as trade minister and information minister before being appointed foreign minister in 2004.
Yeo in a way foretold his fate as one of the more observant PAP members:
An influential figure in the 10-member Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN), he was known as a moderate in a party led by conservatives and graciously accepted his defeat. "A new chapter has opened in Singapore's history, there's a tide which we were not able to overcome," a visibly shaken Yeo told his supporters in a brief speech after his defeat was confirmed in the early hours of Sunday.

On the eve of the vote, Yeo told the pro-government Straits Times newspaper that "there is considerable resentment against the government and its policies, and some of them run deep." He said the PAP, in power since 1959, needed to review its policies regardless of the outcome of the election, or risk further losing touch with the electorate. "We have to listen harder to what people say," he said.
There may be a lesson for even the most progressive of Middle East autocrats (think Jordan or the UAE at least) here. When even one of the most successful examples of authoritarian development suffers popular discontent over heavy-handedness, a lighter touch may be welcome. Try a little tenderness. Note too that these electoral gains have come while gerrymandering to ensure continuing PAP supermajorities has been practised.

If I were the opposition, the new battle cry is clear: "PR" (proportional representation)! Given that PR is usually touted as the solution for breaking through gerrymandering and single-party rule, expect the ruling PAP to be very, very hesitant. Yet, in a city-state as minuscule as Singapore, districting makes very little sense given the scale they have to deal with. Meanwhile, the PAP is likely to give more sops to its people in the form of social services while curtailing migration to appease disaffected voters. It will be interesting to see how Singapore's unbelievably low fertility rate of 1.16 [!] will affect electoral dynamics in the years to come. And do remember that voting is compulsory for Singaporean citizens. It's an odd thing: the PAP has made voting compulsory, but limits the public's ability to entertain alternative opinions and viewpoints.

In the meantime, Singaporean democracy is not an oxymoron.

UPDATE: Lee Kuan Yew has decided to quit his cabinet post in the wake of the elections. For such a seasoned operator, even this limited result in tightly controlled Singapore is flashing some warning signs among the old guard.

Sunday, May 8, 2011

'Pacman' Pacquiao & Fil-Am Protectionism Part 2

Gotta love these alliterative titles. Anyway, my consciousness of legislative machinations was obviously jogged by the fighting congressman Manny Pacquiao eking out a comfortable margin of victory over Shane Mosley. The continuing popularity of the Filipino sportsman Pacquiao in the US--he claims to have secured a senatorial victory for Harry Reid in Nevada where his sporting fame has been cemented--has been covered extensively. While we await the release of the final tally, I expect Indians to have surpassed Filipinos as the second largest Asian minority in the States during the 2010 census. Still, the latter remain a continuing link between former colonizer and colonized. Leftists would of course say this exploitative relationship has never gone away. Perhaps what follows is in this vein.

A few weeks ago, I blogged about the "Save Our Industries Act" which, to my eyes, is a blatantly protectionist measure by the Philippines and United States against China. Key provisions of this bill include the following:
  • Under the 809 component of the program, if the eligible garment's essential character is comprised of U.S.-made fabrics and yarns and is cut and wholly assembled in the Philippines, then it would qualify to re-enter the United States free of duty.
  • In addition, if the eligible garment's essential character is comprised of U.S. spun yarn or extruded yarn formed in the Philippines, it may re-enter the United States at 50 percent of the most favored nation (MFN) duty.
This proposed tag team protectionism involving an industry that has long since seen its better days in the US would not have gathered much attention at all--indeed, I may be the only paying attention to it--had it not been for its high profile proponent, Congressman Pacquiao. Having a rags-to-riches story of his own, he declares that his biggest fight is against poverty. So, aside from training and contesting matches in Las Vegas, his stateside visits have begun to include, well, lobbying for the aforementioned "Save Our Industries Act." For the first time ever comes trade commentary from, er, Sports Illustrated [!]:
His most recent issue involves the United States. Pacquiao is a strong advocate for the Save Our Industries Act, a bill that was introduced to the U.S. Congress in 2009 that would permit Filipino apparel makers to import and use American textiles in the manufacture of certain garments, which they could then export to the U.S. tax free. The passage of this bill would allow the Philippines to compete with China and create more than 200,000 new jobs.

Pacquiao's status in boxing has opened doors for him to lobby for the bill. In February, he met with President Barack Obama. Later, he had a 30-minute meeting with Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid and recruited him to support his efforts. "He went right at Harry," said Pacquiao's promoter, Bob Arum, who was in the meeting. "He zoned in on that issue. He was a real politician. When it was over, Harry told him, 'I'm on it.' "
Given that Sports Illustrated is better known for lowbrow swimsuit issues that have little to do with sports, it's no surprise their commentary doesn't dwell on matters alike deadweight losses or anything of the sort. As mentioned in the earlier post, it appears very hard to reconcile this bill with both countries international trade commitments. Might it squeak by under the Generalized System of Preferences? Perhaps. Then again, it may be a familiar case of pre-match bluster boxers are known for.

Moreover, alike Pacquiao vs. Mosley perhaps, this trade match-fixing exercise is undergoing quarrels between the would-be conspirators as the US wishes to include more exceptions to duty-free imports. That is, it would like to not include certain finished goods it still makes in appreciable quantities. From Fiber2Fashion:
The US has directed Philippines to omit some vital fabric and garment segments, from the proposed list of Philippine-made garments produced from American yarn and fabrics, for which Philippines is seeking duty free access to the US, under the proposed ‘Save Our Industries Act’ bill.

Philippines Trade and Industry Undersecretary Cristino L. Panlilio stated that, he actually doubts if they have an option to not consent to the same. However, he said that, there is a need to fetch a solution to some of the controversial issues that exist between the two countries.

The first issue, he said, is the US wants to exclude ‘poplin’ cloth from the list, as American firms are already producing sizeable volume of apparels from this cloth [hence less need for export processing]. Poplin, which is also known as tabinet, is a sort of medium to heavy weight durable fabric, which is normally produced from cotton or a blend of cotton and polyester. Until last century poplin mainly was used to prepare cotton, silk or heavy weight woollen clothes for winters.

The second issue, he stated relates to undergarments.

It may be recollected that, the ‘Save Act’ bill is an initiative by Philippine, which seeks to revive the local garment and textile industries of both the countries - the Philippines and the US. Philippines is ready to once again put up the bill for approval, during June this year, after making necessary changes to make it more agreeable to the US legislators.
Shadowboxing and trade: who would've thunk it?

Tuesday, May 3, 2011

Asia Learned From Its Financial Crisis; US Didn't

While visiting the website of those famous bond fiends PIMCO, I came across an interesting article on the resilience of Asian economies since the 1997-98 financial crisis. Chia-Liang Lian makes the case that Asia--particularly developing Asia--represents a good investment opportunity. This, of course, comes in tandem with PIMCO's Bill Gross famously dumping malodorous US Treasuries. Times are a-changin': Asian developing countries are now well-placed to secure better credit ratings as you'll read below, while the US is famously set to be downgraded in the likely event that its economolested finances deteriorate even further. While most of us have a mental image of developing Asian countries being reliant on the US market as an export destination, the reality is that the EU surpassed it as such quite a few years ago:
Lian cites reserves as self-insurance (perhaps overdone IMHO), emphasis on fiscal discipline, monetary prudence, and manageable impact from the Japan quake as reasons to expect Asia to carry on nicely. Especially in the fiscal and monetary arenas, there is certainly a contrast of crises evident: While Asian countries learned their lesson (and most European ones to a lesser extent), the United States' money-for-nothing policies have resulted in an unyielding depreciation of its currency and a concomitant disbelief in incredulous policy statements.

But let's not dwell on the hopeless and look at the bright side in Asia. Let's start with Indonesia which was pretty much ground zero of the Asian financial crisis. A scant twelve years on, it is on the brink of realizing investment grade status. Plus, its designation as such by two credit rating agencies should further bolster local capital markets as large institutional investors are given the effective "go" signal. From the Jakarta Post:
It has been more than 12 years since the 1998 Asian financial crisis, and Indonesia still has not managed to regain its investment grade status from rating agencies like Fitch, S&P’s and Moody’s. In the last few years, Indonesia has been blessed with relatively stable political condition, which enabled both portfolio and foreign direct investments to come in. This coupled with strong international commodities prices accelerated Indonesia’s economic growth, resulting in flushed foreign exchange reserves, which reached the highest ever at US$106 billion in March 2011.

The above trends translate to the maturation of Indonesia’s institutions and policy framework, as evidenced also by the easing of the country’s fiscal and external debt burdens stemming from the government’s track record of pragmatic fiscal and debt management policies.

The strong fundamental improvements that we have seen in Indonesia in recent years is the reason why Fitch is looking to upgrade Indonesia’s long-term foreign currency sovereign debt to investment grade sometime in the next 12-18 months. This move, when it materializes, will reinforce the market’s perception that Indonesia has been on the right track. More importantly, the upgrade, reflecting a safer investment destination, would make it possible for a wider universe of international investors, including massive US pension funds, to begin investing into the Indonesian stock market.

However, the real plus for Indonesia will come when a second rating agency also upgrades Indonesia’s rating as large US fixed-income investors, including pension funds and other institutional investors use the Lehman Aggregate Bond Index as their benchmark, which requires two investment-grade ratings in order for a bond to be included in the index. Worth noting is that once a rating agency upgrades, at least one would tend to follow within a year.
Another crisis-affected country to a lesser extent is the Philippines. Alike Indonesia, its macroeconomic picture is looking up, and it has just mounted a roadshow to convince the aforementioned credit rating agencies to consider upgrading it towards similar investment-grade status in the near future. With public debt reduced to 55% of GDP (North American debt lubbers take note: this is not a typo), it isn't a far-fetched goal:
The Philippines is wooing the three major credit rating agencies-—Moody's Investors Service, Fitch Ratings, and Standard & Poor's—-for an upgrade in its credit scores, as economic managers believe the country deserves it amid improving fiscal situation and external liquidity.

Finance Secretary Cesar Purisima told reporters on Thursday that he went recently to New York and Washington D.C. and met separately with representatives of the three credit rating firms. In the meeting, he presented fiscal and monetary data on the Philippines that he said should encourage the rating firms to lift the country's credit scores. He also reiterated the Aquino administration's commitment to meet its medium-term fiscal goals.

The Philippines is rated three notches below investment grade by Moody's, and two notches below the same by Fitch and S&P. Purisima said the credit rating of the Philippines has been lower than that of Indonesia, but added that the fiscal situations of the two countries have been similar. He also cited the country's declining debt-to-GDP [gross domestic product] ratio and deficit-to-GDP ratio. "Our debt ratios and deficit are declining, and our financial sector is well managed, and so we deserve better ratings," Purisima said...

The Philippine government has P4.7 trillion [about $109.6B] in outstanding debts, equivalent to about 55 percent of the country's gross domestic product. This has been brought down from over 70 percent a few years ago.
It remains utterly ludicrous how American deficit deniers believe that even looser money policies than those that brought on the US subprime crisis are the solution to what ails it. I guess the Asians learned from their crisis, but the Americans didn't. Their contrasting public finances tell the story, and even the habitually tardy credit rating agencies are coming around to this fact. Here is the PIMCO conclusion on Asia's sunnier side:
Our conviction of the resilience of emerging Asian countries leads us to be open to adding exposure as attractive opportunities arise. We continue to maintain exposure to emerging Asian currencies. We expect growing acquiescence to currency appreciation as an effective tool to keep imported sources of inflation in check. In this regard, the gradual appreciation trend in the Singapore dollar should remain intact. Despite recent gains, we believe the South Korean won and Chinese yuan remain fundamentally undervalued.

In external credits, select high grade, quasi-sovereign bonds in South Korea and India offer attractive reward opportunities for the risk. We look for avenues to “shake hands with governments” in countries where credit fundamentals are continuing on an upward trajectory. Specifically, Indonesia appears on track to potentially achieve investment grade status in the next twelve months. While the sovereign bonds have largely priced in the prospect of an upgrade, select higher-yielding corporate bonds offer an attractive risk-reward balance, particularly those that have demonstrated a consistent credit record. In the credit default swap market, we look to add, during periods of generalized market weakness, exposure to high quality sovereigns with strong credit metrics.

Monday, April 25, 2011

Singapore Gets on the RMB Trading Bandwagon

In case you missed it, here is more news of the internationalization of the yuan. Singapore and Hong Kong usually duke it out for bragging rights as the financial centre of East Asia. For some time now, the Hong Kong Monetary Authority has experimented with facilitating trade settlement with the Chinese yuan--a first step in making it a more widely used vehicle currency in the region. In the longer time frame which China looks at things unlike shortsighted Americans, first the region then the world. It's a different perspective when you're on the way up instead of the way down.

Being ever so hip to the times, the Singaporeans have gotten on the RMB bandwagon as well. While Hong Kong will still retain advantages dealing in renminbi--it is an erstwhile part of China, after all--it is wary of being left behind. That said, Singapore like Hong Kong possesses the requisite financial know-how, market liquidity, and trading outpost status to make it worthwhile for the (mainland) Chinese to extend RMB trading to. From Reuters:
Beijing's desire to redenominate more of its trade into yuan is giving rise to a new offshore centre in Singapore, but don't expect the same breakneck speed of growth there as in Hong Kong. Many of the commodities that trade in Singapore are the stuff that China needs, though Singapore's trade volumes with China make up only 2 percent of the mainland's total trade, compared with 8 percent in Hong Kong.

Even given Singapore's status as a redistribution center for Southeast Asia and even Western markets, the trade volumes are smaller than Hong Kong. That makes it less likely the city state will see a big spike in renminbi-denominated trade settlement, as Hong Kong saw last year, if China indeed chooses a clearing bank for Singapore's yuan trade.

Then there is the issue of liquidity. Singapore does not disclose official figures on yuan deposits, though the amount is probably a fraction of the roughly 408 billion yuan in Hong Kong's banking system. The market cap of Chinese companies listed in Hong Kong after all is 20 times Singapore's.

All that is not to say Singapore's offshore yuan market would not be successful. Having a clearing bank would accelerate the growth for Singapore's yuan deposits, which on an average earn less than in Hong Kong because of the People's Bank of China backstop line and as the city state's banks have to clear any outstanding yuan deals with Hong Kong, earning lower income in the bargain.

Plus, the city state's big lenders including the likes of DBS [Development Bank of Singapore] and funds like Income Partners and Barclays Capital Fund Solutions already offer renminbi products to customers, forming a launching pad of sorts for an offshore market, albeit a mini version of Hong Kong's.

"As an analogy, if RMB is the product, then China should be regarded as the factory, Hong Kong as the main wholesale market and Singapore something of a retail outlet," Deutsche Bank said in a note [my emphasis].
What is effectively being enabled is access to RMB in Singapore itself for trade settlement without having to course transactions through financial institutions situated either in Hong Kong or the mainland. It is, to be sure, still a more limited system than what Hong Kong has in place since Singapore's availability of RMB is contingent on outside authorities' discretion [read: Chinese capital controls]. Still, it's a significant step in internationalizing the yuan's role as a vehicle currency--especially for Southeast Asia's financial heart.

Here's hoping these experiments work, demonstrating to the PRC that making the yuan more freely traded brings benefits to its issuer. From such experiments flow bigger things desirable in remedying global financial imbalances. The end point, of course, would be making the RMB an openly traded currency on world markets--for all that implies to Chinese capital flows. Full convertibility is not an unrealistic long-term possibility.

Remember, 7% of all trade with China is reportedly now being invoiced in RMB from virtually none two years ago. At such a rate...well, you can extrapolate the endgame. I hope I live to see the day when the Chinese tell the Americans to pay them in RMB after getting fed up with never-ending dollar decimation. That will be the day that the world is freed from dollar hegemony. Maybe we should make it a global holiday ;-)

UPDATE: The FT has a neat story on the Hong Kong v Singapore rivalry.

Wednesday, March 23, 2011

The Slow Road to Southeast Asian Integration

Here is an update on something I follow quite closely from my home region: Southeast Asian economic integration. Unlike the European Union (liberal democracies) or the Gulf Cooperation Council (Islamic monarchies), Southeast Asia possesses countries with a range of political and economic systems. You also observe sizeable economic disparities between countries that span from Myanmar to the virtually first world Singapore.

What's more, differences in institutional capacity mean that economic integration will be bound to occur in fits and starts since the respective starting points and learning curves of these countries are vastly different. As we approach 2015, the stated target date for completing processes of economic integration in the region save for a currency union, let's just say much work remains to be done.

Notably, speakers at a recent Euromoney conference voiced more optimism that the newer CLMV (Cambodia, Laos, Myanmar & Vietnam) member states were better poised to achieve integration target dates more readily, probably since they have not become as accustomed to shielding certain products via sensitive lists that allow for the retention of intraregional tariffs for designated goods. There too remains confusion among exporting firms about the benefits of integration. On this point Christopher Dent notes that the paperwork involved in availing of tariff-free trade often exceeds the cost of just paying the duties--not a good sign--as is the still-low percentage of tariff-exempt trade. Still, it's early days and better cross-border facilitation can go a long way towards making the ASEAN Economic Community something which offers benefits to member countries come 2015. From Xinhua:
ASEAN economic integration will expand trade and investment opportunities among the regional grouping's members, but a full-fledged integration is not seen in the next few years, speakers at a regional conference said on Monday. The grouping is seen most likely to achieve import tariffs cut by its own version of integration while more complicated issues such as customs procedures or investment will be more difficult to be integrated due to the diversity among its members, the speakers said.

The so-called ASEAN Economic Community (AEC) is set to be launched in 2015, integrating a market of over 600 million population in Southeast Asia, or the same size of all European nations, and a combined gross domestic product of over $1.77 trillion.

"2015 is probably a very aggressive target," said Sopon Asawanuchit, executive vice president for corporate finance at Siam Commercial Bank, at a Euromoney conference. Sopon said cooperation in trade was easier to achieve while unifying the members' financial system would need to create a major organizational structure comparable to that of the European Union.

Pornsil Patcharintanakul, deputy secretary general of the Thai Chamber of Commerce, said tariff cut could be expected though the rate would not go down to zero percent for all items as many members keep their "sensitive" products out of the target list.

Others believed Myanmar, Laos and Cambodia, the lesser developed among the grouping's 10 members, could be seen to better integrate into the ASEAN, or the Association of South East Asian Nations, in the next few years. "Our problem is our diversity," said Kobsak Pootrakul, executive vice president for international banking at Bangkok Bank, at the conference titled "The 5th Annual Euromoney Thailand Investment Forum: Continued Growth in Uncertain Times." Kobsak did not foresee the possibility of launching a single currency system in the ASEAN in the near future.

But he and others agreed that members in the ASEAN needed to integrate their economies to make them more competitive globally as each member alone is a small economy. Speakers also saw the need of ASEAN members to learn more about each other in the grouping's integration attempt. Kobsak said 70 percent of Thai companies still did not understand the AEC and how they would benefit from the scheme. He said the integration would provide opportunity for Thai businesses to invest overseas at a time when the country was facing labor shortage and the local currency's value was rising.

Sopon agreed that as currently many Thai businesses needed to employ people from Myanmar due to lack of Thai labor, they should move their operation to the country to enjoy the cheaper wage and the abundance of resources there. He believed that Myanmar would provide a great opportunity for foreign companies to invest for manufacturing there and, then, export products to other ASEAN members.

Monday, March 21, 2011

Would You Stay in Libya as a Nurse for More Pay?

The Philippines is widely recognized as one of the world's top labour exporters. Although its Department of Foreign Affairs began evacuations from Libya shortly after the troubles began like many other countries, it appears that one of its main exports have chosen to stay. Among others, Filipino medical professionals--doctors, dentists, and nurses--have been in great demand abroad as evidenced by their sheer numerical strength.

The situation is no different in the Middle East. With their ability to adapt to local cultures, Filipino nurses--particularly those of Muslim faith--have been practising in these countries. Loath to let them go, it turns out the Libyan government has promised increased pay in exchange for Filipino nurses not leaving the country immediately. While the risk-reward ratio of such an action is debatable, these nurses are hedging on medical facilities not being targets for the pro-Gadhafi forces, the rebels, or the Western no-fly zone enforcers. Risky? Yes, but I hope their safety is indeed what they believe it is. From the Philippines' Daily Tribune:
At least 2,300 Filipino nurses have refused to be evacuated even after the United Nations approved military strikes against Libya. Acting Foreign Affairs Secretary Albert del Rosario said the nurses, 2,000 of whom are based in capital Tripoli and 383 in the rebel stronghold of Benghazi, opted to stay following request from the Libyan government, which promised to increase their pay significantly if they remain.

“We have not received any request to come and provide transport so they can leave Tripoli,” Del Rosario said. “They feel safe being in a hospital and there’s nothing safer than being in a hospital.” But if the situation worsens, he said the government can arrange another ship to pick them up. The government has ended its evacuation in Libya and has moved to safety some 13,000 Filipinos.

Foreign Affairs spokesman Eduardo Malaya said the Filipino nurses chose to stay “in order to fulfill their professional obligation and attend to the needs of the sick and wounded...The safest places for them are the hospitals were they work. Hospitals are considered protected areas under international humanitarian law,” he added.
Matters are complicated by Manila throwing its backing to UN Resolution 1973:
Manila has expressed support to the UN resolution in Libya. Malaya said the Philippines “abides by the decision of the UN security council in imposing a no-fly zone over Libyan airspace as a member of the UN and a signatory of the UN charter. “This UN action is a humanitarian measure which is meant to safeguard the civilian population in Benghazi and other contested areas of said country,” he said.

Recent developments, he added, “will not likely adversely affect Filipinos, as the bulk of our nationals already exited Libya.” The Philippine Embassy in Tripoli will remain open to serve the needs and oversee the safety of the remaining Filipinos there, he said. “Ambassador Alejandrino Vicente and the embassy staff in Tripoli will remain to take care of the country’s interests and ensure the safety of Filipinos who chose to remain for personal reasons,” Malaya said.
And speaking of which, the Philippine government is on the hook for its citizens in several other Middle East destinations where ongoing protests may yet put them in harm's way. Take Syria and Bahrain:
In Syria, Philippine officials there are ready to activate the country’s contingency measures once the political strife worsens. A stock estimate from the Commission on Filipinos Overseas showed 19,423 Filipino workers in Syria. Syrians also took the same path as their neighbors by staging similar loud protests against their authoritarian government, hoping it would result in having their political freedom restored.

“The Philippine Embassy in Syria is closely monitoring developments in certain parts of the country,” Malaya said, adding that the 1,050-strong Filipino peacekeepers stationed in Golan Heights who were deployed to the country as part of a UN peacekeeping contingent can be mobilized to evacuate the thousands of Filipinos if needed.

Meanwhile, Bahrain Prime Minister Shaikh Khalifa Bin Salman Al Khalifa has assured the Philippine government that all Filipinos will be provided protection amid the growing unrest in the Middle East state. Khalifa on Saturday personally relayed this message to Del Rosario, who is currently on five-day Middle East swing to check on the condition of Filipino workers trapped in the spreading conflict across the region.
I suppose this is one of the unspoken responsibilities of mass migration in the 21st century. For, we have an international system where (economic) migrants are ultimately no one's responsibility except for the home country.Given that the Philippines does promote such migration, it's only fair. Then again, there will always be those who are more adventurous--alike the Filipino nurses in Libya.

Sunday, March 6, 2011

Philippine-PRC Spratly Islands Spat + PR Spin

In politics, joining up seemingly unrelated issues is a frequent occurrence. Sometimes it goes by the name horse-trading, other times logrolling. Whatever it's called, there's no escaping it. A few months ago I penned a feature for LSE IDEAS that neatly encapsulates my ideas about China's territorial conflicts with its Southeast Asian neighbours over islands in the South China Sea. So many months after that Hillary Clinton-fuelled diplomatic row, we have another one on our hands. Last week, a Philippine-flagged vessel it calls a seismic surveillance ship was confronted by Chinese vessels in these troubled waters. The PRC calls the surrounding islands Nansha, while the Philippines calls them the Kalayaan ("freedom") islands. In geographic terms, the Red Bank where the incident took place shows you the vastness of China's claim given how much nearer it is to the Philippines (see map point). Feeling aggrieved, the Philippine armed forces scrambled a few planes and boats to look into what was going on, but the Chinese boats had already left the scene when they got there:
Two Chinese Navy gunboats reportedly harassed a vessel owned by the Department of Energy (DOE) that was conducting maritime research off the disputed Spratly Islands last Wednesday. Armed Forces Western Command (Westcom) commander Lt. Gen. Juancho Sabban confirmed that the Air Force deployed bombers and an Islander reconnaissance aircraft while the Navy dispatched three vessels to intercept the two Chinese vessels. “But they did not catch the Chinese vessels that already left when the planes arrived. The DOE ship just resumed their research in the area,” Sabban said in a telephone interview.

Sabban said the incident occurred at around 9:30 a.m. in the vicinity of Reed Bank, 250 kilometers west of Palawan. He said Reed Bank is well within Philippine territory and Navy gunboats were deployed to secure the DOE [Department of Energy] research vessel M/V Venture...

Initial exploration of the Reed Bank by the DOE revealed that the area contains about 3.4 trillion cubic feet of natural gas and 440 million barrels of oil. Sabban said two white Chinese gunboats with the markings No. 71 and No. 75 tried to drive away the DOE research vessel from Reed Bank. The Navy and the Air Force reported that the two Chinese vessels conducted a side-by-side maneuver, virtually “sandwiching” the DOE research vessel, prompting its alarmed personnel to radio for help.
The incident also prompted the Philippine government to file a protest with the PRC:
Manila has filed a formal protest with Beijing after two Chinese patrol boats allegedly harassed a government-authorized seismic survey ship near the disputed Spratly Islands "We have already brought the matter up [with China]. We handed them a protest [letter] on the incident," President Benigno S. C. Aquino III told reporters in an interview after attending a multisectoral dialogue here.

Mr. Aquino also said the country will send to Beijing an expert on the issue to discuss the matter. Pending resolution of the issue, he said a Philippine Coast Guard vessel has been deployed to the area to assist the survey ship. "The Coast Guard ship will ensure that our rights are protected by making sure that this survey ship [authorized] by our government would finish its job," said the President.
The Chinese embassy got a ring from the president's office shortly thereafter:
Meanwhile, "peaceful negotiations" are the way to "solve the dispute, if there is indeed a dispute" over the incident last March 2, said Ethan Y. Sun, deputy chief of political section and spokesperson of the Embassy of the People’s Republic of China in Manila. Mr. Sun said China has always been "committed to maintaining the peace and stability in the South China Sea...If there is dispute between China and the Philippines, this should be made up by peaceful bilateral negotiations," said Mr. Sun in an interview on Friday.

"Aggressive" is not a word he would use to describe any of the recent the actions from the Chinese and the Philippines side, as "it does nothing beneficial to peace and stability in the region." Nevertheless, he maintained that "ever since ancient times, China has indisputable sovereignty over Nansha Islands and their adjacent waters." Nansha is the Chinese name for the Spratlys.

China, Mr. Sun added, has been consistent in upholding the Declaration on the Conduct of Parties in the South China Sea [signed in 2002]. He reiterated a statement made by the Department of Foreign Affairs that the lines of communication between the Philippines and China remain open.

A consideration is that Chinese Ambassador to the Philippines Liu Jianchao will likely return to Manila next week from an annual home office reporting to discuss the matter with the government. "Sometimes it is necessary and more than appropriate to have a high-level exchange," Mr. Sun said.
And now for the joining up of issues. It is well-known that 8 million Filipinos are economic migrants working abroad. As it so happens, some of them just happened to work in Libya. The Philippine press has been critical of what it perceives to be slow government evacuation of its nationals from Libya. While visiting the China Daily, still our favourite official publication, I came across an article which boasts of how China is facilitating the evacuation of other countries' expatriates. As you would expect, including those of the Philippines:
China, in conducting its largest overseas evacuation, helped more than 1,100 foreigners leave Libya over the past two weeks, transporting them on chartered Greek vessels, said China's Ambassador to Greece Luo Linquan. Calling it an act of humanitarianism, Luo said the foreigners were mainly from Greece, Italy, Poland, Bangladesh, the Philippines and Vietnam. A total of 35,860 Chinese citizens had been evacuated from Libya as of Wednesday night, according to the Foreign Ministry. Of these, 20,745 had already returned to China, Vice-Foreign Minister Song Tao said...

Once the maritime evacuation commenced on Feb 22, three Greek ships undertook six voyages from the Cretian capital, Heraklion, to Benghazi and Misurata, two port cities in eastern and western Libya. By Wednesday, more than 13,000 Chinese citizens had been transported to Crete. So far, eight chartered flights have been arranged to take Chinese citizens home...

On the morning of Feb 22, the Chinese government leased two Greek ships to sail to Libya and the vessels departed at 6:50 pm that same day. "The efficiency was unimaginable," as in normal circumstances the process should take days, said Luo.
These seemingly unrelated but ultimately linked occurrences demonstrate a couple of things. First, China would waste the Philippines if hostilities broke out given the former's vastly superior resources. Second, China is still canny in using other diplomatic avenues to win over Philippine friends such as by helping the evacuation of RP nationals from Libya. Third, the Spratly islands issue is not yet out of the limelight, though you'd wish they'd come up with a lasting diplomatic solution sooner or later.

BTW: There is video footage available of the Philippines' modest installation in the disputed islands.

UPDATE: The Philippines is thinking of sending an envoy to China to discuss things. The Reed Bank itself is not being contested according to reports, but the waters in which the incident took place are, hence the entanglement.

Monday, February 28, 2011

Can Manny Pacquiao Knock Out Chinese Textiles?

Yours truly aside, survey after survey usually shows the same phenomenon among Filipinos of having a very favourable opinion of their former colonial masters in the United States. (Having the second largest Asian population Stateside may have something to do with it.) This was true even at the height of global anti-American fervour after the invasion of Iraq. As a minnow in world affairs, minor players like the Philippines need to piggyback on others' efforts. So, when Bush called for GWOT, our government thought "free money from Washington!" and went along. It seems old habits die hard even when the Chinese are now around who are perhaps even more eager to win friends and influence people.

I have thus been following the progress of the "Save Our Industries Act" whose progress has been mixed in the American legislature. Alike nearly every other country in the world, the Philippines and the United States' textiles and garments industries have not been faring well in the face of Chinese competition, especially since the phase-out of textile quotas (the Multi-Fibre Agreement or MFA) in 2005. Go ask Brazil. Sensing an opportunity to ride the wave of Sinophobia as well as industrial survival instincts, both countries have teamed up to try and beat China at its own game by tilting the playing field via political shenanigans.

What does this bill involve? Essentially, US-made fabrics and yarns sent to the Philippines for assembly (undies, t-shirts, trousers, etc.) would be able to claim duty-free re-importation back into America. From the blurb of the "Save Our Industries" website (yes, its proponents have put up an entire site). There is, unsurprisingly, a lot of buddy-buddy rhetoric involved -
--------------------------------

A Historical Partnership: the United States and the Philippines

• The United States and the Philippines share enduring historical and cultural ties. The Philippines, a former U.S. colony, continues to share goals and foster strong political, economic and security relationship with the United States.
• The United States maintains special preference trading relations with all its former colonies, but not the Philippines.
• The Philippines maintains a fair and balanced trading relationship with the United States: In 2008, U.S. exports to the Philippines were US $8.3 billion and the U.S. imports from the Philippines amounted to some US $8.7 billion, while the U.S. trade deficit reached as high as US $10-18 billion with other ASEAN countries.
• The program would continue this balanced, mutually beneficial trade relationship.

SUMMARY OF THE PROPOSED SAVE OUR INDUSTRIES ACT OR THE SAVE ACT

THE 809 COMPONENT:
• Under the 809 component of the program, if the eligible garment’s essential character is comprised of U.S.-made fabrics and yarns and is cut and wholly assembled in the Philippines, then it would qualify to re-enter the United States free of duty.
• In addition, if the eligible garment’s essential character is comprised of U.S. spun yarn or extruded yarn formed in the Philippines, it may re-enter the United States at 50 percent of the most favored nation (MFN) duty.

CUT & SEW RULES FOR SELECTED PRODUCTS:
• Recognizing the success of the 809 component requires a competitive Philippine sewing industry to provide U.S. retailers with a variety of products, the program would also provide duty-free benefits for a limited number of non-import sensitive apparel articles.

ENFORCEMENT:
• Ensuring strict customs enforcement and preventing transshipment of apparel articles is central to the proposed program. The Philippines continues to enforce the Memorandum of Understanding Concerning Cooperation in Trade in Textile and Apparel Goods it signed with the United States in August 2006.
• The Philippines would also establish procedures to allow the U.S. Government access to information for shipments before they reach U.S. Customs, similar to the Electronic Visa Information System (ELVIS), which had previously been in force in the Philippines.

MUTUAL BENEFITS FOR U.S. & PHILIPPINE INDUSTRIES & WORKERS
• U.S. textile and Philippine apparel manufacturers share the same challenges and risks stemming from the end of the U.S. quota system that controlled apparel imports from China until the beginning of 2009. Moreover, over the past several years both industries continued to incur substantial job losses.
• Under the SAVE Act, for the first time, U.S. textile manufacturers would have a meaningful opportunity to compete in Asia in the higher end fashion market in addition to their already established market presence with Western Hemisphere countries, which account for 75 % of U.S. fabric exports.
• The proposed program is designed to facilitate higher levels of trade in textiles and apparel between the United States and the Philippines, to enhance the commercial well being of their respective industries, and to sustain and create jobs in times of global economic hardship.
--------------------------------

And now for the bit I promised with the title on famed boxer / congressman / budding protectionist Manny Pacquiao. The man who's arguably the world's most famous pugilist has been approached by those championing this bill. They're betting on Manny delivering the goods Stateside where they assume he's popular, too. Boxers not being well-known for their modesty, Manny claims that he helped deliver the sizable Filipino-American vote, ensuring electoral wins for Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid and new California Governor Jerry Brown:
“[Reid] was behind 4% in the polls before I got out there,” Pacquiao told The Times on Wednesday before a workout at Wild Card Gym in Hollywood, where he’s preparing for his Nov. 13 junior-middleweight title fight against Mexico’s Antonio Margarito. “There’s a lot of Filipinos in Las Vegas.” Population figures show an estimated 30,000 Filipinos in Las Vegas, with perhaps triple that in all of Nevada. Reid defeated Tea Party candidate Sharron Angle by 40,000 votes, with three-fourths of Asians reporting at exit polls that they voted for Reid.

Pacquiao smiled at the thought of how the assistance he provided a major Washington player could benefit his country in the future. “I also helped Brown here,” Pacquiao said, referring to the governor-elect who defeated Meg Whitman by a more lopsided margin Tuesday. “I helped him campaign. I gave a message to the Filipino community to support Gov. Brown, and they did.”
In addition to recruiting Pacquiao, Philippine trade promotion authorities are spending big on US lobbyists despite taking it on the chin the last time around:
The Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) believes it has a better chance of passing its proposed "Save our Industries Act" bill, which has been refiled in the US Congress recently, as the new bill presents a more comprehensive strategy to justify its passage. "At this point, our chance is 50-50, but I believe we will improve our chances as more sponsors of the bill come in," Trade and Industry undersecretary Cristino L. Panlilio told reporters.

The proposed legislative measure was refiled recently by Senator John Ensign of Nevada. "We are still seeking for additional sponsors to help push this bill," Panlilio said. While the "Save Act" bill is a stand-alone legislative measure, Panlilio said it could still be incorporated or as a rider in other proposed trade bills [whoa, talk about the rest of the world learning dirty tricks of American politics].

In the last US Congress, the Save Act bill was principally authored by Senators Jim McDermott, Daniel Inouye, Kit Bond and Harry Reid. It also gained support from 15 representatives. This time the DTI has adopted a comprehensive approach including the bill’s champion, the extent of activities to be undertaken and a mapping operation of the local industry.

Earlier, Panlilio said that DTI has spent P60 million [about USD 1.4M] in the last two years, including that of the DTI leaders of the past administration and the new government in pushing for the passage of the bill. Panlilio said the bulk of this money went to Washington consultants who helped in the crafting of the bill, but which failed to pass in the last US Congress.

The P60 million formed part of total of P250 million that have been spent on various initiatives for the garment sector out of the P650 million industry fund, which represents the revenues generated from the fees in administering the garments export quota by the defunct Garments and Textile Export Board.

The lobby to push for the bill in the US Congress started in 2009 that resulted in the filing of the bill in June of that same year. The DTI had mounted several initiatives to lobby for the passage of the bill including tapping the Filipino-American communities in the U.S. and a viral marketing campaign that also involved Rep. Manny Pacquiao, who is again endorsing the bill. “Last year this administration conducted two missions to the U.S. for this bill, but the bulk of the expenses involved the consultancy fees for the experts that the government had to hire,” Panlilio said.

Under the Save Act bill, the Philippines will produce garments using American textile, yarns and fabrics. The finished product would then be exported to the U.S. duty-free. This bill is seen as a win-win solution to revive the ailing textile industry in the U.S. and revive the garments manufacturing of the Philippines. The passage of the Save Act is expected to revive the country’s garment industry that used to export over $3 billion and employ over 600,000 people because exports of garments to the U.S. using American yarns and fabrics would be allowed duty-free access in the U.S. market.
For those of you who are trivia buffs, IPE junkies, or textile industry followers, the Garments and Textile Export Board mentioned above was a Marcos-era creation designed to administer Philippine garments and textiles export quotas during the Multi-Fibre Agreement (MFA) era. With the lapse of MFA in 2005 under WTO strictures, it is not only developed but also developing countries who've been scrambling to contain China's exporting powerhouse.

This bill is interesting as a collaboration between a former textile oppressor (the US which largely set up the MFA) and the oppressed (the Philippines) when faced up with an even more formidable foe in China. Still, I have some simple questions I'd particularly like Philippine trade officials to answer:
  1. Isn't this Act a blatant violation of WTO principles of non-discrimination?
  2. Given its lack of American legislative success and possible WTO litigation, aren't limited Philippine trade promotion funds better spent elsewhere?
  3. What is the wisdom in the Philippines siding with a falling world power (the United States) and offending a rising one (China)?
Given the likely answers to these questions, I think "Save Our Industries Act" is a really bad idea. Then again, I don't set Philippine policy--but I'll bet a boxer seeking to KO Chinese imports does [!?]

UPDATE: After consulting with Simon Lester of the IELP blog, he suggests that US/Philippine attempts to include this Act under the Generalized System of Preferences (exemptions from WTO rules) is unlikely. Given that the phasing out of MFA was meant to remove such exceptions, I'd say international momentum is against this bill's champions.