Showing posts with label Cheneynomics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cheneynomics. Show all posts

Monday, June 27, 2011

Potpourri: $ Losing Global Status, $100B AAA Loss

A few hours ago we received word that River Plate, the most storied of Argentinian football clubs which has helped spawn many global footballing legends, was relegated from the first division for the first time in its 110-year history. This resulted in riots in Buenos Aires. How the mighty have fallen! It of course got me thinking about another tarnished has-been in the United States of America. Yes it's falling quite fast in various global league tables, but when will it finally be banished from the commanding heights of the world economy? As you'd expect, the dollar being the leading reserve currency and US Treasuries' AAA status are two indicators under pressure.

I am of the opinion that America deserves to be kicked in the balls as hard as possible as just desserts for its boorish financial behaviour. Plus, there's the added benefit of punishing those continuing processes of subprime globalization by hurting both American debtors and creditors alike. In this vein we have two noteworthy and promising developments. First, UBS recently polled central bankers holding a total of $8 trillion in reserves about the future make-up of these assets. It seems most are getting fed up with America as sentiment towards the currency is diminishing even further as the dollar approaches all-time lows on any number of indices. End result? Most see a movement towards a portfolio of various currencies quite soon:
The US dollar will lose its status as the global reserve currency over the next 25 years, according to a survey of central bank reserve managers who collectively control more than $8,000bn. More than half the managers, who were polled by UBS, predicted that the dollar would be replaced by a portfolio of currencies within the next 25 years.

That marks a departure from previous years, when the central bank reserve managers have said the dollar would retain its status as the sole reserve currency. UBS surveyed more than 80 central bank reserve managers, sovereign wealth funds and multilateral institutions with more than $8,000bn in assets at its annual seminar for sovereign institutions last week. The results were not weighted for assets under management.
Good stuff. However, I am even more anxious to see an even swifter and harder kick delivered to Uncle Sam's (rather minuscule) nuts. For instance, I've covered some dire scenarios of what may happen if the US does not raise its $14.3 trillion debt ceiling and effectively defaults on its obligations. While unlikely--an undisciplined and unprincipled debt addict will never refuse a larger fix, just you wait and see--don't forget that America's creditors would also take a hit. Which, again, is part of the attraction since those who bankroll American debt addiction have it coming too.

And we don't have to wait for an outright credit event; a downgrade will do in financially waterboarding America's foolish creditors who fully deserve such treatment. McGraw-Hill estimates potential losses to US bondholders can amount to some $100 billion:
Investors in the US government bond market could face losses of up to $100bn if the largest economy loses its triple A rating, according to a research arm of McGraw-Hill, the parent of Standard & Poor’s. A ratings downgrade that results in higher bond yields and lower prices could also mean the US Treasury paying $2.3bn-$3.75bn a year more in interest on financing a $1,000bn annual budget deficit.

“If Standard & Poor’s or any of the other major rating agencies downgrade the US, Treasuries would likely drop in value, possibly by as much as $100bn,” said analysts at S&P Valuation and Risk Strategies, a research team separate from the agency.
As an American leader of recent vintage liked to say, bring it on. Time waits for no one; ask River Plate.

Wednesday, June 8, 2011

Junk Treasuries: Time for US 'Technical Default'

In three simple points, let me explain the concept of subprime globalization before moving on to the enticing prospect of American sovereign debt being junked in 2011:

1. Free money policies have done America next to no good;
2. These free money policies are ultimately costly in adding to the burden of already heavily indebted future American generations;
3. LDCs that should know better are piling public monies better spent on public goods alike health and education into funding wasteful, pointless American spending.

While slagging America is admittedly a pastime in these parts because it is so fun, easy, and morally justified with generous helpings of righteous fury, I am of the mind that the free-spending fool is just that bit less stupid than those footing the bill of the free-spending fool (LDCs purchasing Treasuries).

No matter; we have some very encouraging news that, while not in the realm of immediate probability, still points to the famously tardy credit rating agencies--those same folks whose rating prowess was on display during both the Asian financial crisis and subprime crises--recognizing what the rest of us already know. Yes, American Treasuries are utter rubbish. Following S&P, last week Moody's placed the US under credit watch for a downgrade from AAA status if nothing was done to improve its fiscal picture as soon as July. Now, however, comes news that Fitch will consider a "technical default" by the US as a credit event worthy of dropping the status of Treasuries to junk as soon as August. A technical default simply means that, the US Treasury having exhausted all artifices in avoiding a breach of the $14.3 trillion debt ceiling which has not been raised, fails to honour American obligations.

So, it seems to me that we have two options here. First, we can continue with subprime globalization from which no one benefits--the US and its similarly brainless creditors, or receive a taste of America's bankrupt future via "technical default." I am all for the latter. You can call me a dreamer, but it seems Republican Tea Party folks are not ruling out such a default to (they say) prod the US on a more sustainable fiscal path. See some representative responses [1, 2, 3]--especially to an earlier WSJ interview urging it. Even the Chinese are affecting displeasure at this possibility--I wonder why. Anyway, to this informative Reuters story:
U.S. Treasury bonds, seen worldwide as the risk-free investment [yeah sure], could be labeled "junk" if the government misses debt payments by Aug. 15, credit agency Fitch Ratings warned on Wednesday. The ratings would go back up once the government fulfills its debt obligations, but probably not to the current AAA level, Fitch said on Wednesday in a stark statement about the impact of a short-lived default on U.S. credit-worthiness.

The statement follows similar warnings by Moody's and Standard & Poor's, but Fitch was the first among the big-three rating agencies to say U.S. Treasury securities could be downgraded, even for a short period of time, to a non-investment grade.
Of course, I am fully encouraging the Tea Partiers to pull the trigger (or flush America down the toilet) now since even worse things are in store for their debt-loving country anyway on its present, unsustainable trajectory:
The idea of a brief U.S. default, sometimes called a technical default, has been growing among some members of the Republican Party, who believe it would be an acceptable price to pay if it forces the White House to deal with runaway spending.

"Even a so-called 'technical default' would suggest a crisis of 'governance' from a sovereign credit and rating perspective," Fitch said in a statement...Clearly the political signals which are coming (from Washington) are a source of concern," David Riley, head of sovereign ratings at Fitch, told Reuters in an interview.

Treasury bonds could be rated "junk" by Fitch Ratings if the government misses some $82 billion in debt payments by Aug. 15 due to disagreement over the debt ceiling. The ratings would go back up once the government fulfills its debt obligations but probably not to the current AAA level, Fitch said.

President Barack Obama is trying to win congressional approval to raise the borrowing authority before an Aug. 2 deadline. The Treasury Department said on Wednesday the Fitch warning was "another stark reminder" of the need for Congress to act quickly.
Mark 2 August on your calendar; hopefully, Congress will have done nothing by then:
Fitch said it would first place U.S. ratings on "watch negative" if lawmakers fail to enact an increase in the U.S. debt ceiling by Aug. 2, the date when the Treasury Department will have run out of extraordinary measures to avoid a default.

The first test for U.S. ratings will come two days later when $30 billion in Treasury bills mature. If the government fails to repay them in full, Fitch will lower the rating on those specific securities to B-plus, four notches into junk territory.

But the real deadline comes on Aug. 15 when $27 billion in Treasury notes and $25 billion in coupon payments come due. If the government misses those, Fitch would downgrade the U.S. sovereign issuer ratings to "restricted default" and lower all Treasuries securities to B-plus.

"Though such an event (such as a short-lived Treasury bill default) may not permanently impair the capacity of the U.S. government to service its obligations, it is unlikely that its 'AAA' status would be retained in the short to medium term," it added...Moody's credit rating agency warned last Thursday that it could consider cutting the United States' top-notch credit rating if there was not progress by mid-July on a deal to reduce the deficit and raise the $14.3 trillion U.S. debt limit.
It's time to call a spade a spade. Americans love all sorts of junk: junk food--witness their gut-busting levels of mega-obesity; junk mortgages--witness the subprime fiasco; junk assets (ditto); junk as in making the most garbage--see here...and they'll learn to love junk Treasuries, too. Life is what you make of it, and modern American finances are, well, you can figure that one out. To save the world from subprime globalization, America must literally pay the price for its boorish behaviour.

Thursday, May 19, 2011

Guns or Butter? UK's Defence v Foreign Aid Debate

OK, so this is not strictly an application of the economic textbook guns-or-butter question of whether a nation should devote its resources to military or civilian priorities given a production possibility frontier. After all, the recipients of the "butter" ain't her majesty's subjects. Given that the UK is not as free-spending as the US is--over there Cheneynomic free lunch ideology has been ascendant for at least a decade now--it's a meaningful tradeoff with implications for foreign policy. PM David Cameron says he's of the "Live Aid" generation in justifying the preservation of aid spending, but let's say right-leaning sorts have...other priorities.

The general outlines of this debate go like this: The Conservative-Liberal government indicates that it will live up to its coalition agreement to "ring fence" or protect 0.7% of British GDP for foreign aid by shielding it from government cuts occurring elsewhere. (See an earlier post of mine on how the 0.7% of GDP target came about.) To which the defence secretary, unsurprisingly, wishes to keep the option of reducing foreign aid contributions to spend on arms. Protect your turf is still the operating principle here. That is, more guns, less butter:
Defence Secretary Liam Fox has challenged a plan to enshrine in law the UK's promise to spend 0.7% of its gross national income on overseas aid. In a letter leaked to the Times, Dr Fox says he "cannot support the proposal in its current form". A source close to Dr Fox said the issue was not the level of the target but how best to reflect this in law.

Downing Street said it remained fully committed to implementing its pledge in line with the coalition agreement. The BBC understands Dr Fox's letter was written to Prime Minister David Cameron about five weeks ago. The defence secretary said that "creating a statutory requirement to spend 0.7%" on overseas aid could lead to legal challenges and limit the government's options on where money was spent.

International aid is one of only a handful of areas, including health spending in England, being ringfenced from spending cuts over the next four years. Most other departments are seeing their budgets slashed - defence spending by 8% by 2015.
Given that foreign aid is less than a third of defence spending as the graphic in the link in the article indicates. What's more, the UK has some ways to go to reach the 0.7% threshold from its current level of below than 0.6%:
The promise to spend 0.7% of national income on aid by 2013 was put in the Conservative manifesto before the last general election and then repeated in the coalition agreement. A Downing Street spokesman said it was "fully committed to enacting the 0.7% commitment into law, in line with the coalition agreement". The 0.7% commitment is an international aspiration first mooted by the United Nations in the 1970s and reaffirmed by the world's leading economies in 2002.

Aid and development charity Oxfam said Dr Fox was "wrong" to question the government's approach. "British aid offers great value to the taxpayer," its chief executive Barbara Stocking said. "For little more than a penny in the tax pound we not only help those in need but also boost our standing in the world and increase our influence in the global corridors of power."
In the real world where the rest of us live in where deficits do matter (got that, Yankee deficit lubber?), these debates are more than rhetorical.

Sunday, May 15, 2011

Fire Sale USA or the Desperate States of America

Here's a very pertinent news article I almost forgot to post about. Imagine America as one big pawnshop and you wouldn't be far off as federal, state, municipal, household and individual entities are in various states of distress. In particular, what's an increasingly desperate collection of United States (in debt) to do but hock the family jewels? It's the same strategy for households on the brink of bankruptcy or an equally sorry collection of states whose finances are very nearly beyond salvation. In North Carolina, for example, some observers believe that the state intends to mostly do away with providing K-12 education altogether. Maybe it's time to sign up to the NC Hope Coalition for those being affected.

A few weeks ago, we had LSE IDEAS' very own Niall Ferguson write about how selling off the good bits of America can be a measure to help raise American revenue. Given that all American states except Vermont have some sort of balanced budget law, recent hard times have been accompanied by Greece-inspired fudges and kludges. Like with all Cheneynomic commentary, the numbers just don't add up for these states. No matter; eventually, the stench of US fiscal decay escapes and the odour ain't pleasant. So, aside from slashing services left, right and centre--taxes are still a bit more difficult to push through with the American electorate--what is this motley collection of states to do? You got it--Fire Sale of the States is well underway:
The Great Government Tag Sale is on. As states and cities struggle with billions of dollars in shortfalls, elected officials are increasingly selling public assets to cover their costs. Sometimes municipalities sell the buildings to pocket a one-time pile of cash and then lease them back so they can continue to use them.

To proponents, selling government property is an efficient way to plug budget holes. That's one reason the Obama administration has looked at unloading office towers, courthouses, warehouses and shacks. Private owners who develop the properties can inject vibrancy into municipal dead zones, the thinking goes. Buildings that were once exempt from property taxes are put back on the rolls.

But to critics, these sales are as misguided as pulling money out of your house to pay your bills. They point out that the government is letting go of a long-term, valuable asset in exchange for a one-time payment. When the asset is a building, a municipality then has to spend more money on leasing it back or renting another facility...
There is no alternative? Well, it's pretty close:
Years of wishful budgeting and fiscal gimmickry have finally caught up. The states' "ridiculous" budget and pension accounting would "make Enron blush," as Microsoft founder Bill Gates recently put it. For fiscal 2012, states face a $125 billion shortfall, according to the Center for Budget and Policy Priorities.

Elected leaders have already raided road-repair budgets and borrowed from emergency-service coffers. They've nabbed citizens' unclaimed checking account cash and sold future proceeds from lotteries. Detroit and Omaha just reduced the pensions of the police. Now that other options have been exhausted, officials say that to avoid mammoth tax hikes — or any tax hikes, in some cases — they have no choice but to sell municipal assets.
Also see the informative TIME "Broken States of America" piece detailing this lot's sorry fate. The downside of these one-off sales is precisely that they can be only done once. So the stock of saleable assets will only keep dwindling unless some major turnaround in state finances occurs. Don't count on it, however.

Friday, May 6, 2011

Intertwined Fates: bin Laden and the €500 Note

OK, so the absurdist image to the left was Photoshopped by someone with too much free time, but I have more sartorial commentary on bin Laden that is more factual. While we all know that the dollar is currently on another downward spiral necessitating another comical "strong dollar" statement from the hapless US treasury secretary (comical Tim-E?), let's again take stock of where it stands among household names whose familiarity is not necessarily down to wholesome activities. Brazilian supermodel Gisele Bundchen reportedly refuses to be paid in ratty US dollars. Meanwhile, gangsta rap artist Jay-Z sports a briefcase full of €500 notes in a music video--a far cry from when those engaged in this trade used to wear big gold "$" chains. These kinds of notes have also become favoured among the global gangster class (the real sort unlike Jay-Z & Co.) for whom money laundering is a regular activity alike walking the dog.

Although the existence of €500 notes is common knowledge, it's rather few of us who've actually seen it in person. Hence, they've become known as "bin Ladens" in British slang:
The 500 euro note, one of the largest denomination notes in the world, is being pulled from distribution in the United Kingdom. They are known in some countries as "bin Ladens" - the bank note everyone knows exists, but few people other than criminals will ever see. The decision comes after police linked 90 per cent of these notes in circulation to crime, tax evasion and terrorism. The UK's Serious Organised Crime Agency (SOCA), which has been studying currency trading, has concluded the 500 euro note is at the heart of money laundering because it is so easy to move.
It has come to pass in recent news reports that the eponymous Usama bin Laden (deceased) was found wearing a €500 note stitched into his robe along with two important phone numbers. This observation has occasioned some fanciful conjectures. F'rinstance, Slate has a novelty feature guessing how far bin Laden could have gone with this sum:
[U]sama Bin Laden had two telephone numbers and 500 euros in cash sewn into his clothes, CIA Director Leon Panetta told lawmakers this week. That's about $740, or around 60,000 Pakistani rupees. Presumably, if Bin Laden had evaded the SEALs, his disciples would have covered his travel, food, and lodging costs. But, hypothetically, what's the farthest you can get from Abbottabad on 500 euros?
You can read the rest at the link. However, I believe that we have some important political-economic commentary here that exceeds its sartorial value. Get this: even if bin Laden's brain had wasted away to the point that key phone numbers had to be sewed into his garments, he still knew that "strong dollar" policy was unreal from a hideaway with no fixed-line telephone or Internet. Aside from a $740 or so equivalent note being far handier than a $100 one, the hawkish bias of the ECB compared to its Federal Reserve free money counterparts is obvious even to what accounts suggest was an already doddering bin Laden.

And so it would have been written as an epitaph had American helicopter dropping operatives not dumped his body: 'Here lies Usama bin Laden. He died with a "bin Laden" stitched into his active wear.' If a senile rabble-rouser could figure out that holding dollars was a fool's game, well, I pity those who still do. Something else that's receiving an extrajudicial execution at the hands of America is, well, the US dollar.

Thursday, May 5, 2011

Americans Agree America's Future Stinks (Duh)

Ah, the stench of American decay. Just a few hours ago, I heard Joseph "Soft Power" Nye--a worthy inaugural recipient of this blog's Carl Spackler Award for Cheneynomic analysis--outline his case that America's demise is much exaggerated. As you'll read below, I take issue with his argument that while the US may be in relative decline, it is not in absolute decline. But let's begin though with some decidedly non-rose-tinted analyses of America's prospects by regular folks. While deficits don't matter-style reasoning is nothing new as far as Americans academics are concerned, it's good to hear what Americans who live outside of ivory towers have to say instead of having USA#1 cheerleaders feed us a steady diet of Bush league bromides. Save it for the next Sarah Palin rally, buddy (as the Yanks would say).

Once again demonstrating you don't have to look far for IPE-relevant material, I came across this nugget on the Yahoo! homepage. A few posts back I used "green card" petitions as a gauge of just how much America stinks since skilled migrants are choosing not to go there in droves. No jobs, no future, no go. Well guess what: Americans themselves agree that America stinks. Due to a lack of jobs among other things, today's US youth is resigned to a living standard inferior to that of their parents'. The recent Gallup poll mentioned below is in a long line of polls asking basically same question "Will today's generation be better off than their parents'?" The headline says it all: "In U.S., Optimism About Future for Youth Reaches All-Time Low":

And here's the relevant accompanying text:
Forty-four percent of Americans believe it is likely that today's youth will have a better life than their parents, even fewer than said so amid the 2008-2009 recession, and the lowest on record for a trend dating to 1983.

Confidence in the traditional American dream--that each generation can work its way up in the world and have a better life than the previous generation--appears to be slipping away. Americans are less likely to believe this to be true today than at any time on record, including during the worst of the recent economic crisis.

Fewer than 4 in 10 high-income Americans--who presumably have the greatest access to opportunity and resources to gauge what the markets will do going forward--believe today's youth will be better off than their parents. This level of pessimism may also reflect the massive destruction of wealth that high-income Americans experienced from the economic meltdown.

Young adults, however, are mostly hopeful that today's youth will have a better living standard, better homes, and a better education than their parents. This optimism among youth -- their belief that tomorrow can be better than today -- is an important and hopeful sign, but it is possible that as they age, these young Americans will become more pessimistic, as their elders are today.
I've said this before and I'll say it again: The American dream is a fraud. (Perhaps criminally so in the case of the subprime crisis.) Now, there are three versions of this tall story: owning your own home, the land of opportunity, and a rising standard of living. First you have the idiotic "ownership society" variant which begat the housing bubble. As home prices keep tumbling with no end in sight, it's no surprise that homeownership rates keep falling, too. So much for that. Second you have the observation that intergenerational mobility is worst in Anglo-Saxon countries alike the US and UK [1, 2] where laissez-faire is supposed to promote more opportunity. No such thing, either. Third, Americans have good reason to be pessimistic about the living standard of future generations since median incomes have already been in decline for a decade. I learned about "extrapolation" in the fourth grade, and it's not a very difficult idea to grasp (unless you subscribe to mathlexic Cheneynomics, listen to Brooks and Dunn, or are a Tea Party acolyle, of course).

So there you go, Joe (Nye). The American dream, so central to its aspirations, is not supported by fact. Collapsing home prices, class immobility, and falling median income--if that's not outright decline, then my name's Abe Vigoda. Increasingly, Americans themselves don't believe in the American dream as it sinks further into Cheneynomic oblivion. Tell me this: where is the "soft power" of persuasion when your own people don't believe in this fraud? Few except the most deluded buy it, so you might as well consign it to the dustbin of history. The evidence is indisputable that America is in decline--and Americans are increasingly convinced of it, too.

Tuesday, May 3, 2011

Asia Learned From Its Financial Crisis; US Didn't

While visiting the website of those famous bond fiends PIMCO, I came across an interesting article on the resilience of Asian economies since the 1997-98 financial crisis. Chia-Liang Lian makes the case that Asia--particularly developing Asia--represents a good investment opportunity. This, of course, comes in tandem with PIMCO's Bill Gross famously dumping malodorous US Treasuries. Times are a-changin': Asian developing countries are now well-placed to secure better credit ratings as you'll read below, while the US is famously set to be downgraded in the likely event that its economolested finances deteriorate even further. While most of us have a mental image of developing Asian countries being reliant on the US market as an export destination, the reality is that the EU surpassed it as such quite a few years ago:
Lian cites reserves as self-insurance (perhaps overdone IMHO), emphasis on fiscal discipline, monetary prudence, and manageable impact from the Japan quake as reasons to expect Asia to carry on nicely. Especially in the fiscal and monetary arenas, there is certainly a contrast of crises evident: While Asian countries learned their lesson (and most European ones to a lesser extent), the United States' money-for-nothing policies have resulted in an unyielding depreciation of its currency and a concomitant disbelief in incredulous policy statements.

But let's not dwell on the hopeless and look at the bright side in Asia. Let's start with Indonesia which was pretty much ground zero of the Asian financial crisis. A scant twelve years on, it is on the brink of realizing investment grade status. Plus, its designation as such by two credit rating agencies should further bolster local capital markets as large institutional investors are given the effective "go" signal. From the Jakarta Post:
It has been more than 12 years since the 1998 Asian financial crisis, and Indonesia still has not managed to regain its investment grade status from rating agencies like Fitch, S&P’s and Moody’s. In the last few years, Indonesia has been blessed with relatively stable political condition, which enabled both portfolio and foreign direct investments to come in. This coupled with strong international commodities prices accelerated Indonesia’s economic growth, resulting in flushed foreign exchange reserves, which reached the highest ever at US$106 billion in March 2011.

The above trends translate to the maturation of Indonesia’s institutions and policy framework, as evidenced also by the easing of the country’s fiscal and external debt burdens stemming from the government’s track record of pragmatic fiscal and debt management policies.

The strong fundamental improvements that we have seen in Indonesia in recent years is the reason why Fitch is looking to upgrade Indonesia’s long-term foreign currency sovereign debt to investment grade sometime in the next 12-18 months. This move, when it materializes, will reinforce the market’s perception that Indonesia has been on the right track. More importantly, the upgrade, reflecting a safer investment destination, would make it possible for a wider universe of international investors, including massive US pension funds, to begin investing into the Indonesian stock market.

However, the real plus for Indonesia will come when a second rating agency also upgrades Indonesia’s rating as large US fixed-income investors, including pension funds and other institutional investors use the Lehman Aggregate Bond Index as their benchmark, which requires two investment-grade ratings in order for a bond to be included in the index. Worth noting is that once a rating agency upgrades, at least one would tend to follow within a year.
Another crisis-affected country to a lesser extent is the Philippines. Alike Indonesia, its macroeconomic picture is looking up, and it has just mounted a roadshow to convince the aforementioned credit rating agencies to consider upgrading it towards similar investment-grade status in the near future. With public debt reduced to 55% of GDP (North American debt lubbers take note: this is not a typo), it isn't a far-fetched goal:
The Philippines is wooing the three major credit rating agencies-—Moody's Investors Service, Fitch Ratings, and Standard & Poor's—-for an upgrade in its credit scores, as economic managers believe the country deserves it amid improving fiscal situation and external liquidity.

Finance Secretary Cesar Purisima told reporters on Thursday that he went recently to New York and Washington D.C. and met separately with representatives of the three credit rating firms. In the meeting, he presented fiscal and monetary data on the Philippines that he said should encourage the rating firms to lift the country's credit scores. He also reiterated the Aquino administration's commitment to meet its medium-term fiscal goals.

The Philippines is rated three notches below investment grade by Moody's, and two notches below the same by Fitch and S&P. Purisima said the credit rating of the Philippines has been lower than that of Indonesia, but added that the fiscal situations of the two countries have been similar. He also cited the country's declining debt-to-GDP [gross domestic product] ratio and deficit-to-GDP ratio. "Our debt ratios and deficit are declining, and our financial sector is well managed, and so we deserve better ratings," Purisima said...

The Philippine government has P4.7 trillion [about $109.6B] in outstanding debts, equivalent to about 55 percent of the country's gross domestic product. This has been brought down from over 70 percent a few years ago.
It remains utterly ludicrous how American deficit deniers believe that even looser money policies than those that brought on the US subprime crisis are the solution to what ails it. I guess the Asians learned from their crisis, but the Americans didn't. Their contrasting public finances tell the story, and even the habitually tardy credit rating agencies are coming around to this fact. Here is the PIMCO conclusion on Asia's sunnier side:
Our conviction of the resilience of emerging Asian countries leads us to be open to adding exposure as attractive opportunities arise. We continue to maintain exposure to emerging Asian currencies. We expect growing acquiescence to currency appreciation as an effective tool to keep imported sources of inflation in check. In this regard, the gradual appreciation trend in the Singapore dollar should remain intact. Despite recent gains, we believe the South Korean won and Chinese yuan remain fundamentally undervalued.

In external credits, select high grade, quasi-sovereign bonds in South Korea and India offer attractive reward opportunities for the risk. We look for avenues to “shake hands with governments” in countries where credit fundamentals are continuing on an upward trajectory. Specifically, Indonesia appears on track to potentially achieve investment grade status in the next twelve months. While the sovereign bonds have largely priced in the prospect of an upgrade, select higher-yielding corporate bonds offer an attractive risk-reward balance, particularly those that have demonstrated a consistent credit record. In the credit default swap market, we look to add, during periods of generalized market weakness, exposure to high quality sovereigns with strong credit metrics.

Sunday, May 1, 2011

Special FX: What is 'Strong Dollar' Policy, Exactly?

My, my, my--have we been here before. And I suspect we have far from heard the last of it lest 'weak dollar' policy becomes a rhetorical favourite in certain parts of North America. When it comes to sheer hypocrisy, the 'strong dollar' policy quite possibly tops a very lengthy list of vapid statements emanating from American officials. Originating from the Clinton administration--more specifically Robert Rubin's selection as US treasury secretary--all who've succeeded him have been made to repeat this mantra regardless of the actual value of the dollar. Larry Summers is arguably the last to have put his mouth where the dollar was at. Meanwhile, the Bush tax cuts, the bursting of the dot-com and housing bubbles, and military adventurism have taken their toll on the state of American finances as America transitioned into Bush 43's "big government conservatism."

Just as Bush's treasury secretaries Paul O'Neill, John Snow, and Henry Paulson famously had to repeat the "strong dollar" line, so does Obama's own Tim Geithner. If anything else, Obama has overseen an even more remarkable deterioration in US finances. Hence, as the dollar flirts with all-time lows on any number of fronts, what I previously mentioned has come to pass: To avoid an outright rout of the US dollar but not actually help in any substantial way, Geithner was forced to repeat the increasingly empty 'strong dollar' line late last week. (Footage of Geithner's speech is available online.) Anyway, on to the Bloomberg report on this sorry restatement of a transparent falsehood:
Treasury Secretary Timothy F. Geithner today reaffirmed the U.S. commitment to a “strong dollar” and said the country won’t weaken the currency to gain an advantage over its trading partners. “Our policy has been and will always be, as long as at least I’m in this job, that a strong dollar is in our interest as a country,” Geithner said in remarks at the Council on Foreign Relations in New York. “We will never embrace a strategy of trying to weaken our currency to try to gain economic advantage [my emphasis].”

Geithner’s comments, in response to a question about the dollar’s recent decline, show his efforts to reassure investors that the U.S. will restore long-term economic growth and stability. The Treasury chief said the U.S. must earn investor confidence “over time” and said there’s “fundamental” trust in the U.S. ability to cope.
If only the markets had more belief in this pronouncement. Maybe he should repeat it some more as others don't seem to be listening yet:
The dollar dropped for a sixth day against the euro, matching the longest losing streak since May 2009, on speculation the Federal Reserve will consider measures to keep yields low to support the U.S. economy. The greenback also fell to almost the lowest level since August 2008 against the currencies of major U.S. trading partners...

Geithner said today that the U.S. needs a “credible strategy” to reduce its budget deficits over time, without moving too quickly and choking off economic recovery. “You have to commit to bring the budget deficit down to a level that will put our overall debt burden on a declining path as a share of the economy,” he said. The Obama administration wants to move onto that path by about 2015, he said.
The thing is, of course, that there is no guarantee that the Obama administration will still be around come 2015. Geithner then gets back to the immediate need to raise the US debt ceiling from its current $14.3 trillion lest it be breached come 19 May. Which of course is jarring insofar as calls for fiscal responsibility are mentioned in the same breath as pleas to be given the permission to issue more debt:
Geithner also said Congress needs to act by June to raise the debt limit, saying it would be “irresponsible” and “unacceptable” not to act. “The idea that the United States would take the risk people start to believe we won’t pay our bills is a ridiculous proposition,” he said. Congress is facing a vote as early as next month on raising the $14.3 trillion debt ceiling. The Treasury Department projects that it will hit the cap on May 16, though it could use emergency measures to avoid default until about July 8.

The chairman of the Treasury Borrowing Advisory Committee today said it would be “catastrophic” if the U.S. did not raise the limit. The advisory committee includes representatives from firms including Goldman Sachs Group Inc. and Bank of America Corp. “Any delay in making an interest or principal payment by Treasury even for a very short period of time would put the U.S. Treasury and overall financial markets in uncharted territory, and could trigger another catastrophic financial crisis,” Matthew Zames, chairman of the advisory panel, wrote in a letter to Geithner released in Washington today. Zames is a managing director at JPMorgan Chase & Co.
Geithner then mentions high oil prices as a hindrance to America's economic recovery without mentioning the likelihood that a weak dollar is in reality causing price spikes in many commodities--including oil:
Geithner said today that oil prices have become an obstacle to growth for the U.S. economy, which is otherwise set to accelerate. “We started the year with a little less momentum,” Geithner said. “We’ve got some new headwinds, most prominently of course in oil,” Geithner said. “What’s happening in oil is obviously potentially very significant. At current levels, on its own, it won’t put the recovery at risk.”
So what exactly does he mean by "strong dollar" policy that is not evident to me? By any conventional measure of the dollar's value--the broad index or major currencies index in nominal or real terms, the real effective exchange rate, etc--the US dollar is slumping towards all-time lows once more, period. There's also the charge that American free money policies are causing speculative flows to buoy commodity values he has yet to rebut as mentioned above.

This sort of hooliganism (see my comments on 'strong dollar' bulls--t being typical Yanqui behaviour) reflects an increasingly incoherent America. As its massive deficits inevitably weigh on its currency, it no longer possesses the willingness or ability to shore up its currency. In other words, it is more than willing to take dollar holders for another in an endless series of rides. That is, "strong dollar" statements no longer carry the weight they did during the Clinton administration. When you can no longer convince others of the integrity of your currency but have to resort to cheap talk which is totally disconnected with reality, well, the lie is revealed all too easily. Uncle Sam is a confidence man.

And if you're dumb enough to hold dollars--or believe 'strong dollar' talk for that matter--there's no one to blame but yourself.

Thursday, April 21, 2011

Shorting America: $ Swoon Chronicles, 2011 Edn

[NOTE: It's time for rubbish collection again, and today's point of collection is familiar to all.] I am rather incredulous about others' fixation on the minimal movement on Treasury yields since S&P dropped its credit warning on the unsuspecting American public. First, it's early days--other agencies have yet to follow. Second, it's only a warning, not an actual downgrade. So, there's plenty to, well, look forward to if your interested in obtaining a (marginally) more honest picture of American fiscal decrepitude, moral turpitude towards the global economy, and overall bad attitude. Then again, Americans famously have no idea of long-term outlook, so you shouldn't expect any better from its commentariat class.

In the meantime, fear not for general sentiment towards the US dollar is falling hard pretty much across the board: against currencies of developing countries and developed countries; commodities; and what else have you. Let's just say that, alike the credit warning, there are plentiful signs of folks losing faith in America. As you can see in the chart above, the dollar index spot (DXY) has hit a three-year low, while all-time lows are not far away last plumbed in 2008.

It's during these times--when dollar weakness threatens to turn into an outright dollar rout--when the Treasury Secretary usually starts taking about "strong dollar" policy. In reality, of course, he's more interested in seeing it devalue--but not become a runaway situation which dents whatever confidence remains in holding greenbacks--AKA American junk. From Reuters:
The dollar fell broadly for a third straight day on Thursday as record low interest rates and the crushing weight of the U.S. budget deficit pushed it closer to an all-time trough against major currencies. The dollar's slide accelerated days after Standard & Poor's slapped a negative outlook on the United States' top AAA credit rating. The agency said a downgrade was possible if authorities can't slash the massive U.S. budget deficit within two years. That prompted investors, from fund managers to foreign central banks that hold trillions of dollars in assets, to opt for anything but the U.S. currency.

"The combination of loose monetary policy and chaos on the fiscal front has people very worried," said Boris Schlossberg, head of research at GFT Forex in New York. "That fear is being reflected in the dollar." Mohamed El-Erian, co-chief investment officer of PIMCO, with $1.2 trillion in assets under management, said, "Absent problems elsewhere in the world, history and economics suggest that America's current fiscal and monetary policy stance will put continued pressures on the dollar."

The dollar index, a gauge of the greenback against six advanced country currencies, fell to 73.735 .DXY, its lowest level since August 2008. Analysts said that sets up a possible run toward its record low of 70.698 touched in March 2008.
People are losing faith in the common currency? You must be reading blogs populated with USA#1-style cheerleaders and other reality-challenged folks:
The euro soared to a 16-month high above $1.46 before easing to $1.4550 EUR=, while the dollar fell 0.8 percent to 81.82 yen JPY=. The Australian dollar rose above $1.07, its highest in nearly three decades, as Australia's 4.75 percent interest rate and its role as a supplier of raw materials to booming Asian markets attracted investors.

Some investors fear a fragile U.S. economic recovery could sputter if the White House and Congress agree to cut the deficit with significant spending cuts or tax hikes. That would likely force the Federal Reserve to hold interest rates at record lows even as other central banks raise them. "There is no clear sign that the U.S. is going to raise interest rates, and that is causing the dollar to depreciate by the day," said Jonathan Xiong, who helps manage about $30 billion at Mellon Capital Management in San Francisco...

Analysts said the euro was on course for a move toward $1.50 if the current momentum continues, despite the possibility of a Greek debt restructuring. Talk that China may invest in Spain had investors shrugging off worries for now about euro zone debt.
So the market is guessing America's woes are far worse than those of the Eurozone--and I use a non-fallacious indicator via their currencies. Factor in endless bouts of depreciation and extraordinarily low rates and investing in America is as raw a deal as you can get. If you're dumb enough to do so, well, you'll have no one to blame but yourself for the worst is yet to come--and few will argue about that.

Tuesday, April 19, 2011

Easy to Tell if China or Japan US Ally After S&P

Whose strategic interests are more aligned with those of the US, China or Japan? While the latter occasionally acts up such as after being asked to open its market to unsaleable US cars in the 90s, it knows when to toe the line. Geopolitically speaking, Japan relies on the US military to keep its own defence expenditures down and to sort out troublesome neighbours alike North Korea and, for that matter, China.

Speaking of which, China is more of a free agent willing to honour the principle of non-intervention to seek raw material and energy supplies where it pleases, Western human rights happy talk aside. In a more strictly financial sense, we see the contrast most clearly in the aftermath of S&P rightly putting the US on a negative outlook for its triple-A credit rating. Having had the experience of being banished from triple-A status itself, the Japanese should know.

What's more, Japan is wary of criticizing the US for obvious reasons given its own bloated public debt (but not so much of the foreign-sourced variety; more on this later). While Japan strives to preserve a system that saw itself rise on America's coattails in the postwar world economy, the Chinese are looking to chart a course of their own. Yes, it may take decades or centuries, but never let it be said that the Chinese don't plan ahead:
While Japan played down concerns about US creditworthiness after the decision, China’s foreign ministry on Tuesday urged Washington to protect investors in its debt. “We hope the US government will take responsible policies and measures to safeguard investors’ interests,” it said.

The Chinese government has repeatedly called on Washington not intentionally to debase its currency and to protect the interests of foreign investors in its bonds. China’s foreign reserves increased by $197bn in the first quarter to $3,050bn, exceeding the symbolic $3,000bn mark for the first time. The reserves are the world’s largest by far and although their exact composition is regarded as a state secret, about two-thirds are believed to be invested in US dollar assets.

According to US data, China held $1,154.1bn in US Treasuries at the end of February, making it the largest foreign holder of US debt ahead of Japan’s $890.3bn. The Federal Reserve is the largest overall holder of US Treasuries with $1,368bn on its books.

Senior Chinese officials, including Zhou Xiaochuan, central bank governor, have said that China needs to reduce its foreign exchange holdings and to improve and to diversify its reserves from any over-reliance on US dollar assets. However, the sheer size of China’s reserves means there are no other asset markets in the world large or liquid enough for China to stash its increasing cash pile.
$1 trillion in reserves was already unfathomable to me; $3 trillion is utterly incomprehensible. To be sure, the Chinese keep complaining about America's evident death wish on the dollar's value for all that implies on China's holdings. As I've said before, those fooled by the free-spending fool are the bigger fools. Still, China's willingness to berate the Americans is potentially another warning.

Or maybe not. On to $4 trillion in reserves!? Talk about subprime globalization. In any event, it's clear who owes more to whom among Asia's economic giants and is more willing to play by a set of rules from an increasingly bygone era.

Monday, April 18, 2011

Yippee, S&P Cuts US Credit Outlook to Negative!!!

Sometimes I'm so glad to be mistaken. I've often thought that the political economy of credit rating agencies went like this: The likes of Standard and Poor's, Moody's, and Fitch's would never downgrade American sovereign debt since the US government held the ultimate ace. That is, it could remove their status as Nationally Recognized Statistical Rating Organizations (NRSROs) if they did not play along. Just as these credit rating agencies happily slapped "AAA" ratings on all sorts of subprime securities which turned out to be utter rubbish, they've been more than willing to grant the US government the highest credit rating of them all. I've always attributed it out of fear of being cast out of the world's biggest capital market by losing their designation as NRSROs. Certainly, an entity that is for all intents and purposes bankrupt and is intent on staying the course deserves Grecian doubt.

But wonder or wonders, S&P has now downgraded the outlook on American sovereign debt to negative. Which, of course, is the prelude to a full-blown credit downgrade. As you'll read below, there is now a one-in-three chance of this happening in the next two years. While I write, the DJIA is down 200+ points as a knee-jerk reaction (to the inevitable?) Just when I was set to enjoy a peaceful Holy Week, these folks butt in. From the ever-reliable Bloomberg:
Standard & Poor’s put a “negative” outlook on the AAA credit rating of the U.S., citing a “material risk” the nation’s leaders will fail to deal with rising budget deficits and debt. “We believe there is a material risk that U.S. policy makers might not reach an agreement on how to address medium- and long-term budgetary challenges by 2013,” New York-based S&P said today in a report. “If an agreement is not reached and meaningful implementation does not begin by then, this would in our view render the U.S. fiscal profile meaningfully weaker than that of peer ‘AAA’ sovereigns.”

Longer-term Treasuries fell, reversing earlier gains, after S&P lowered its outlook to negative from stable. The cost to protect against a default by the government and the nation’s banks jumped and stocks declined after the New York-based ratings firm’s action, which assigns a one-in-three chance that it will lower the U.S. rating in the next two years.
As noted, the markets are in disarray. The cost of insuring American trash--I mean Treasury bonds--has been rising, too:
“It’s truly a shot across the bow and a message to Washington, which has been clowning around on this and playing politics when they should toss ideology aside and focus on achievement,” said David Ader, head of government bond strategy at CRT Capital Group LLC in Stamford, Connecticut. “The bond market is still trying to find out what to make of it. People don’t know what to do. If you sell Treasuries, what do you go in to? No one knows...”

The cost to protect against losses on Treasuries in the credit-default swaps market jumped to the highest in 11 weeks. Credit-default swaps on U.S. Treasuries climbed 7 basis points to 48.5 basis points as of 10:25 a.m. in New York, according to data provider CMA. That’s the highest level since reaching 49.4 basis points on Feb. 1 and means it would cost the equivalent of 48,500 euros a year to protect 10 million euros of debt against default for five years...
Why so? I don't think there's any mystery here as the US has been the only major industrialized country to pile on debt at an astonishing pace. So it is that there is now a 33% chance of America losing its AAA status within two years:
The U.S. is the only large AAA rated country that saw its debt rise during the crisis that until recently had no plan that would reverse the trend, Steven Hess, senior credit officer at Moody’s, said last week.

The negative outlook by S&P means that the firm views a one-in-three chance it will cut a borrower’s rating within a two-year horizon, David Beers, S&P’s global head of sovereign and international public finance ratings, said in a Bloomberg TV interview. “This debate in the country really is just beginning and hard choices are going to have to be made,” Beers said. “We’re not saying that no agreement is possible. We’re just unsure as to the time frame and whether it’s going to be seen as credible not just by us but by the broader marketplace.”
A welcome development indeed. As before, I am fully on board with the idea that whacking America via penalty rates is the way to go to get some semblance of normalcy in the world economy. Among other things I would like to see:
  1. The other two major agencies (Moody's & Fitch's) following suit with a negative outlook;
  2. Rising long-term interest rates Stateside sufficient to dent the housing-industrial complex; and my absolute favourite...
  3. US default on its debt due to failure to raise its debt ceiling come May--the starkest foretaste of them all
Serves them right. More of this, please!!!

UPDATE: The FT has a copy of the S&P credit watch report. The following reasons are given as to why "peer" AAA countries (the UK, France, Germany and Canada) are on a more sustainable path than the US, having already begun processes of fiscal consolidation:
While thus far U.S. policymakers have been unable to agree on a fiscal consolidation strategy, the U.S.'s closest 'AAA' rated peers have already begun implementing theirs. The U.K., for example, suffered a recession almost twice as severe as that in the U.S. (U.K. GDP declined 4.9% in real terms in 2009, while the U.S.'s dropped 2.6%). In addition, the U.K.'s net general government indebtedness has risen in tandem with that of the U.S. since 2007.

In June 2010, the U.K. began to implement a fiscal consolidation plan that we believe credibly sets the country's general government deficit on a medium-term downward path, retreating below 5% of GDP by 2013. We also expect that by 2013, France's austerity program, which it is already implementing, will reduce that country's deficit, which never rose to the levels of the U.S. or U.K. during the recent recession, to slightly below the U.K. deficit.

Germany, which suffered a recession of similar magnitude to that in the U.K. (but has enjoyed a much stronger recovery), enacted a constitutional limit on fiscal deficits in 2009 and we believe its general government deficit was already at 3% of GDP last year and will likely decrease further.

Meanwhile, Canada, the only sovereign of the peer group to suffer no major financial institution failures requiring direct government assistance during the crisis, enjoys by far the lowest net general government debt of the five peers (we estimate it at 34% of GDP this year), largely because of an unbroken string of balanced-or-better general government budgetary outturns from 1997 through 2008. Canada's general government deficit never exceeded 4% of GDP during the recent recession, and we believe it will likely return to less than 0.5% of GDP by 2013.
I've blogged about how the Canadians set the standard for intelligent discussion on how to broach the issue of fiscal consolidation to the public. Contrast this to the pro wrestling-inspired shenanigans Stateside and I needn't explain why the US is such a train wreck. Next stop: going off the rails on the crazy train America.

Monday, March 7, 2011

Why "Who Owns the US?" is a Trick Question

OK, so I may have been (partly) at fault on this one. A few years ago, I ran a feature on "Don't Offend the Chinese, the Real Owners of America." The basic premise of that article went like this: America is broke while China is rich. Although this fact is self-evident, most of the support China lent to the US was in the form of Treasuries. Given Treasuries' measly returns, it wouldn't be too long before the Chinese snapped up prime American companies. To be sure, this occurrence has yet to pan out since the so-called enterprising Americans keep citing specious "security" concerns in limiting Chinese purchases of US firms. Still, it probably won't be long before foreigners tire of buying low-yielding American sovereign debt given that appetite isn't infinite as some would suggest. But don't take my word for it; ask Barry Eichengreen.

In accounting terms, assets are equivalent to liabilities plus owners' equity. This is one of the first things a business major learns. National accounting is not quite identical but is similar in one very important respect: holding another's debt is not the same thing as ownership. You don't receive voting rights or ownership stakes by holding debt but by owning equity (shares of stock). Additionally, US Treasuries are akin to corporate debentures in being unsecured. Investopedia has a neat explanation:
[Debentures are] a type of debt instrument that is not secured by physical asset or collateral. Debentures are backed only by the general creditworthiness and reputation of the issuer. Both corporations and governments frequently issue this type of bond in order to secure capital. Like other types of bonds, debentures are documented in an indenture.

Debentures have no collateral. Bond buyers generally purchase debentures based on the belief that the bond issuer is unlikely to default on the repayment. An example of a government debenture would be any government-issued Treasury bond (T-bond) or Treasury bill (T-bill). T-bonds and T-bills are generally considered risk free because governments, at worst, can print off more money or raise taxes to pay these type of debts.
So that's straightforward as far as the US goes. Another type of liability is called secured debt which entitles lenders to specific assets in the event of default. A simple example would be a home mortgage. Back to Investopedia:
[Secured debt is] backed or secured by collateral to reduce the risk associated with lending. An example would be a mortgage, your house is considered collateral towards the debt. If you default on repayment, the bank seizes your house, sells it and uses the proceeds to pay back the debt.

Assets backing debt or a debt instrument are considered security, which means they can be claimed by the lender if default occurs.
Insofar as Treasuries are alike debentures, their holders cannot claim specific government-owned assets in the case of American default in this instance. So, I roll my eyes when I read headlines like this one by Main Street that appeared in Yahoo! on "Who Owns the U.S?" Armed with the knowledge above, spot the elementary howler:
While most of the country's $14 trillion debt is held by private banks in the U.S., the Treasury Department and the Federal Reserve Board estimate that, as of December, about $4.4 trillion of it was held by foreign governments that purchase our treasury securities much as an investor buys shares in a company and comes to own his or her little chunk of the organization.

Looking at the list of our top international creditors, a few overall characteristics show some interesting trends: Three of the top 10 spots are held by China and its constituent parts, and while two of our biggest creditors are fellow English-speaking democracies, a considerable share of our debt is held by oil exporters that tend to be decidedly less friendly in other areas of international relations.
Wrong, wrong, wrong. I would flunk the writer straight out of Accounting 101. For the same reason that bondholders aren't shareholders, foreigners owning Treasuries have no ownership stakes in America, period. This article was meant to be a comment on US financial illiteracy as illustrated by America's towering debts, but the honest truth is that it reflects the writer's own financial illiteracy. You should see the comments on the article that are even more astoundingly ill-informed. I honestly despair for the US when this sort of thing is shared 23,000 times on Facebook and is retweeted 613 times.

Are people really this gullible? Maybe social media really is making us dumber. Some fools fool themselves I guess, but they're not fooling me.

Wednesday, September 1, 2010

Why Total Debt/GDP Hides West's Sick Finances

Constantly travelling around, I meet all sorts. I've met folks who worked for Enron, the US military in Iraq, and a private military company operating there--and I'm talking about the same guy (bada-boom)! Today, however, one of my other contacts has delivered on something that has piqued my interest which (thankfully) doesn't involve violence like that in Iraq. Still it involves quite a bit of fraud like Enron and accounting for US expenditures in Mesopotamia.

In recent days, both FT Alphaville and the Becker-Posner blog commented on a recent Morgan Stanley report fetchingly titled "Ask Not Whether [Developed] Governments Will Default, But How." It is the first in a series of reports concerning "Sovereign Subjects." The main gist of the report is that it is not possible for major developed countries to meet their obligations given current demographic and economic trends. Now, this is plenty obvious to everyone but the most jaded mathlexics who are unfortunately all too common in the blogosphere--especially America#1-style cheerleaders who try to make up for their proud ignorance with ideological blinders. Being a more curious and open-minded sort, I asked a colleague to fetch me a copy of this Morgan Stanley report to see for myself.

Before getting to the juicy bits, I must mention that parts of it are available on the MS Global Economic Forum. Brad Setser used to link there a lot, but I guess the blogosphere kind of forgot about it despite GEF still having some interesting free content. What the author Arnaud Mares points out is that the ratio of total debt to GDP is a misleading indicator of just how fiscally shot developed countries are for a number of reasons. Essentially, it is a backward rather than forward-looking indicator. Those who actually bother to do the math will find little new here, but it bears repeating:
---------------------------------

Four reasons why debt/GDP misses the point. The problem with these historical comparisons is not the reference: how governments dealt with their war debt burdens sheds useful light on what might be in store for coming years. Rather, the problem lies with the measurement tool: debt/GDP is the most widely used debt metric, but we believe that it is a very inadequate indicator of government solvency. There are four reasons for this:
  • Gross versus net debt: First, debt/GDP is a measure of gross indebtedness. It therefore overstates the size of the government's net financial liabilities, especially when - as has been the case through the crisis - debt is being raised for the purpose of on-lending or acquiring assets. Where measures of net debt exist, they provide an apparently less alarming picture of the government's balance sheet. The difference can be sizeable (in excess of 17% of GDP in the UK currently, for instance). Good news, however, stops here.
  • Missing liabilities: The second flaw of debt/GDP is that it only accounts for part of a government's contractual liabilities. There exists a broad range of liabilities that are debt, yet are not captured in national accounts. To take one example, in March 2008 the UK Government Actuary Department valued the government's unfunded civil service pension liabilities - that is, the contractual claims on government accumulated to date by civil servants - at £770 billion. That is 58% of GDP, not captured by the debt/GDP ratio. Debt/GDP does not capture contingent liabilities either.
  • It is not GDP but government revenues that matter: Whatever the size of a government's liabilities, what matters ultimately is how they compare to the resources available to service them. One benefit of sovereignty is that governments can unilaterally increase their income by raising taxes, but they will only ever be able to acquire in this way a fraction of GDP. Debt/GDP therefore provides a flattering image of government finances. A better approach is to scale debt against actual government revenues. An even better approach would be to scale debt against the maximum level of revenues that governments can realistically obtain from using their tax-raising power to the full. This is, inter alia, a function of the people's tolerance for taxation and government interference. Seen from this angle, the US federal debt no longer compares quite so favourably with that of European governments.
  • Debt/GDP looks at the past. The main problem is in the future: The fourth and largest flaw of debt/GDP is that it is an entirely backward-looking indicator. It only accounts for the accumulation of past deficits. This captured reasonably well the magnitude of the fiscal challenge at the end of World War II because at that time the challenge did indeed result entirely from the past: large wartime deficits had pushed debt ratios higher, but governments were no longer running deficits, nor were there expectations of them doing so in subsequent years.
By contrast, the accumulation of past deficits now represents only part of the problem for advanced economies' governments. The other part consists of coping with the large structural deficits opened up by the crisis and compounded by the fiscal consequences of ageing. What raises questions about debt sustainability is not so much current debt levels as the additional debt that will accumulate in coming years if policies do not radically change. Debt ratios do not capture this part of the problem.
---------------------------------

It's me again. I suggest that you closely read the portion concerning how "It is not GDP but government revenues that matter" above. When you recompute these developed states' power to tax against their obligations, we come up with a familiar result. You might say primitive-mathlexic American politics exist in a reality-free zone where debate still surrounds whether to extend Bush 34's tax cuts despite the enormous harm they've done to America's long-term fiscal prospects. While US lawmakers are really quite bad at math, so too are the folks who elected them: Many say they're concerned about spiralling deficits, but they also say taxes shouldn't be increased. The end result of this brand of free lunch economics? Well, see for yourselves:

That's right, boys and girls. The US is in worse fiscal shape than Greece after adjusting for America's extreme aversion to tax increases and revenue generation. The tax haul there is so low and it's likely to stay that way. And don't even get me started on the finances of individual states. In the end, Americans get the government they deserve as it fully reflects their sheer ignorance of economic reality. See ya, and I definitely wouldn't wanna be ya.

Saturday, August 28, 2010

ECB's Trichet: No-BS Talk to Yankee Debt Lovers

ECB President Jean-Claude Trichet should be most familiar to readers as the anti-Bernanke. Although his institution has certainly taken some unconventional measures to help put out fires in Europe, their magnitude pales in comparison to those taken by the self-described Yankee helicopter pilot. Unsurprisingly, Bernanke has gone on talking about policy options for further easing.

A few weeks ago, Trichet wrote an op-ed in the Financial Times that developed economies should stimulate no more. Only yesterday, Trichet attended the central banker jamboree in Jackson Hole, Wyoming, where he took the opportunity to warn his easy money American colleagues about the perils of their actions. While his entire speech is a tour de force that requires close reading, below is an excerpt concerning what the US has most likely in mind. That is, the Yanks think that living with the debt is not particularly harmful. Trichet, however, would like to disagree with this misdiagnosis:
What about the option of “living with the debt”? Some have suggested to ignore existing financial imbalances “for the time being” and focus only on the short term. Rather than pressing on with the deleveraging process, more spending could be encouraged to sustain growth in the short term.

I believe that adopting this view would be very dangerous for our economies. There is a very clear example of the consequences of choosing to live with the debt: Japan in the 1990s. The “lost decade” in that country was the result of allowing the banking system to remain fragile over many years.

Banks appear to have contributed to economic weakness by rolling over the bad debts of inefficient firms. Banks’ inadequate capitalisation implied that they were unwilling to take losses. Low productivity growth in those inefficient firms and the locking in of capital and labour put a drag on potential output. Only a healthy financial system is able to provide funding for good projects that spur productivity and innovation.

The lesson from past history is that dealing with the legacy of accumulated imbalances is not simply a duty to be fulfilled after the economic recovery, but rather an important precondition for sustaining a durable recovery. The primary macroeconomic challenge for the next 10 years is to ensure that they do not turn into another “lost decade”.

This lesson is consistent with economic theory and evidence. Since the time of Irving Fisher, economists have explored the impact of a legacy of indebtedness for growth. In various ways, these analyses suggest that an excessive debt burden – whether emanating from the corporate, household or public sector – constitute a drag on spending, thereby dampening growth.

For firms, for example, high indebtedness reduces their net worth and the ability to borrow for new projects. Consequently, firms will postpone investments until they are able to restore sound balance sheets. Similarly, households’ precautionary saving could remain high until their wealth-to-income ratios return to more normal levels, following the collapse in asset values at the peak of the crisis.

Economic growth can also be threatened by high public indebtedness, which, without a credible fiscal retrenchment plan, can generate substantial uncertainty. Firms and households know that ultimately they will have to bear the consequences of the painful measures needed to reduce debt. As long as it is unclear when the adjustment will occur and who will bear what fraction of the costs of adjustment, firms and households may delay their investment and consumption decisions, slowing down the economic recovery. In the data, evidence points to the existence of a negative association between the level of public debt and subsequent GDP growth, which is particularly marked at high debt levels.

Finally, the debt overhang can make it attractive for governments to adopt regulatory measures that compel the financial and/or household sectors to hold government debt at low or even negative real interest rates – measures referred to as “financial repression”. Forced investment in government bonds distorts the role of the financial system in channelling resources to the most efficient firms and slows down economic growth. While the effects of financial repression on growth are particularly severe, these effects may also occur through excessive financial regulation.

So the option of ‘living with the debt’ indefinitely is not a solution to the challenges currently facing policy-makers, nor is it a means to ensure sustainable economic recovery. We must focus on policies to address the debt overhang.
Ricardian equivalence, baby; don't leave home without thinking about it. On America's current trajectory, perhaps folks won't be talking about Jackson Hole but the Bernanke Hole.

Wednesday, August 25, 2010

Michael Fay Revisited: World Should Cane America

[NOTE: This is the first of two Singapore and America posts.] Most of you are probably old enough to remember the Michael Fay caning incident of 1994. A typical American wastrel in the Bart Simpson mould named Michael Fay was punished for allegedly spray painting cars in Singapore. Now, that city-state is famed for its cleanliness and orderliness as compared to certain other places. (Like, say, the great American city of Detroit.) For Fay's troubles, the delinquent was thrown in the gaol, and most famously, caned four times. Fay became an American media sensation, with all sorts of wusses appealing for clemency for one of their own. It also had the effect of making Singapore (temporarily) known to Americans who are famously incurious about the rest of the world.

Of course, this kid would have received six lashes were it not for the intervention of Bill "I Feel Your Pain" Clinton. Feeling aggrieved by Singaporean no-nonsense rules, then-United States Trade Representative Mickey Cantor even tried to suggest the city-state was not a proper host of a 1994 World Trade Organization event. At the end of the day, however, what the Singaporeans suggested in reply sticks: America is better off sorting its own issues that telling the rest of the world what to do.

The intervening years have brought us full circle to present-day America. What have we learned since then? Well, for one thing, that Singapore was right to hold up the mirror to American indiscipline as manifested by the likes of Fay and similar louts. Let's just say America still has fearsome issues dealing with self-control and self-discipline. Some time after returning home, Fay was found to be sniffing butane. As you probably have figured, the plight of America is that of Michael Fay writ large. The US is an addict not to butane but to debt. Just as Fay had all sorts of apologists: "Oh, he's just a kid" (he was actually 18 by then), and "Oh, he was diagnosed with ADHD"; so does America have its share of "deficits don't matter" mathlexics and stimulus junkies with nothing to show for.

The larger point is that, unfortunately, the rest of the world has been lax in caning America and tossing it in the gaol for even more outrageously loutish behaviour. By gladly funding this wastrel nation, the rest of the world has encouraged all sorts of pointless megaspending to no one's particular benefit, Like those that came before it which reached this point of decline, the fundamental identity of America on the world stage is somewhere between a bully and a hypocrite. If you don't push back, it shows no compunction in economolesting you and telling you it's for your own good. Maybe it'll throw in some freedom and growth shtick for good measure.

Some ask, "Why is the world economy so shambolic?" In reply, let's ask "Why doesn't the rest of the world discipline the financial rogue regime that has done the most to vandalize it?" Soon I will write more about how to put America in its place. Certainly, all evidence points to its current indiscipline doing no good for itself or for others.

Following the example of the archetypal Yankee offender Michael Fay, what must be done is clear: Cane it till it's deservedly red, white, and blue. It's high time someone beat some sense into America before it's too late. I guess some folks had the good sense to try and drum discipline into the US so many years ago given the waste it has become.

Tuesday, August 24, 2010

Funding Carry Trade w/ $, Currency of the Doomed

It is common knowledge by now that next to nothing is going right in the US economy. America's various debt orgies have brought it little but additional misery. Deficit lovers thought they could revive this wasteland by borrowing even more humongous amounts to cure ills caused by borrowing too much in the first place. In the end, nobody feels sorry for America--except perhaps Martin Wolf, who's become something of an apologist for Anglo-Saxon orthodoxy as of late. It's justice served: if you act foolishly, you fully deserve what's coming to you.

As if we needed even more proof of the descent of this economic wasteland comes even more news of its pointless existence. Briefly, the "carry trade" is one of the most basic plays in foreign exchange. One borrows in a currency charging lower interest--the "funding currency"--and lends in a currency yielding higher. In the past, nearly zero-yield Swiss francs and Japanese yen were the favourite funding currencies of foreign exchange traders. However, a comatose US economy has meant policymakers keeping similarly low interest rates Stateside.

Voila! The dollar is now becoming a funding currency of choice. Not only is it yielding next to nothing, but limited expectations of the US escaping the ambit of its self-inflicted and wholly deserved financial ruin mean many are willing to use the dollar as a cheap and stably moribund funding currency. That is, a funding currency is best provided by an economy with few growth prospects that may require interest rate rises to cool down. Reuters explains this latest piece in the puzzle of American decline:
While the dollar is still far from surpassing the Japanese yen and the Swiss franc as the world's funding currency of choice, investors are no longer rushing to buy the greenback as a safe haven any time trouble erupts worldwide. While not inherently bad for the dollar, being a funding currency is a sign of investors' disenchantment in U.S. economic growth and return potential. In time, countries with funding units face difficulty attracting foreign investment, further eroding economic prospects and the attractiveness of their currency.

On Thursday for example, the dollar sold off against both yen and Swiss franc after a report showed factory activity in the U.S. Mid-Atlantic region unexpectedly contracted. Both currencies are lower yielding than the dollar, making them better funding options. Until recently investors would have sold them and bought back dollars after the headlines.

The move on Thursday "was not a flight into U.S. dollars, but a flight out of the dollar," said Douglas Borthwick, a managing director for trading at Faros Trading LLC, a forex execution firm in Stamford, Connecticut. "If the dollar is no longer seen as the destination for the 'flight to safety' then the market will use it as the currency to be short against high-yield trades given it will shield them the most from adverse moves," he added. "Thus it would become the funding currency of choice."

In the forex markets, a funding currency is used to finance so-called carry trades. A carry trade involves borrowing in a low yielding currency to buy higher yielding assets elsewhere. High liquidity, low yields and low volatility are all desired traits in a funding currency. The Japanese yen fit all of those attributes for years, making it popular for trades involving the Brazilian real, the Mexican peso and the Australian dollar.

"There's a possibility the dollar will be just like the yen a couple of years ago," said Dean Malone, a currency director at Compass FX in Dallas, Texas, which sold U.S. dollar versus Swiss francs on Thursday. "With yields these low, there's simply very little appreciation value in the dollar," he said. "Until we turn the corner, until employment picks up and the Fed decides to start raising interest rates, markets will keep looking for higher returns elsewhere. And the dollar may be used to help fund those trades..."

Some analysts are cautious however on reading too much into the dollar's recent trading behavior. They note that when taken into account the implied volatility and yield spreads across currency pairs -- key measures to help gauge a carry trade efficiency -- the dollar doesn't stand out as a funding unit.

Analysts at RBC Capital Markets compile a "carry value barometer," which ranks funding currencies, using option prices and measuring yield spreads adjusted for volatility. According to the bank's latest reading the Canadian dollar is now the best funding currency, in particular for trades involving the Australian dollar, South African rand, the Brazilian real and the Turkish lira.

In comparison, the dollar ranked between the 4th and 6th best option among 8 currencies, involving the same pairs. "No doubt the low yields are hurting the dollar," said Todd Elmer, a G10 currency strategist for Citigroup Inc. in New York. "But I'm not sure about selling it to buy the yen and the Swiss franc for some potential marginal yield gain."
I don't need to spell out what it means when some traders view USD as a better funding currency for the carry trade than the yen given the state of the Japanese economy for the last two decades. We knew it all along: America stinks and so does its currency. Long live the carry trade! I think it's time I took a punt on AUD/USD...